Logo
NFLNFL

With Eli Manning giving way to Daniel Jones for the rookie’s first career NFL start on Sunday against Tampa Bay, Jones will become the first Giants rookie quarterback to start a game since Manning himself did it in 2004.

Here’s a look at how other Giants rookie quarterbacks have fared in their first career starts:

Eli Manning

When drafted: First round, No. 1 overall, 2004

First rookie start: Nov. 21, 2004 vs. Atlanta (loss)

Stats in debut: 17-for-37, 162 yards, one TD, two INTs

Eli Manning during his first career start in 2004.APEli Manning during his first career start in 2004.AP

Kent Graham

When drafted: Eighth round, No. 211 overall, 1992

First rookie start: Nov. 26, 1992 at Dallas (loss)

Stats in debut: 12-for-28, 151 yards, zero TDs, zero INTs

Phil Simms

When drafted: First round, No. 7 overall, 1979

First rookie start: Oct. 7, 1979 vs. Tampa Bay (win)

Stats in debut: 6-for-12, 37 yards, zero TDs, zero INTs

Jim Crocicchia

When drafted: Undrafted (replacement player during 1987 strike)

First rookie start: Oct. 5, 1987 vs. San Francisco (loss)

Stats in debut: 6-for-15, 89 yards, one TD, zero INTs

Scott Brunner

When drafted: Sixth round, No. 145 overall, 1980

First rookie start: Dec. 7, 1980 at Seattle (win)

Stats in debut: 8-for-18, 161 yards, two TDs, one INT

Joe Pisarcik

When drafted: Undrafted (signed in 1977 after three years in CFL)

First rookie start: Oct. 9, 1977 vs. Philadelphia (loss)

Stats in debut: 12-for-38, 193 yards, one TD, four INTs

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy