ED Harris gives another terrific performance as a priest suffering from a crisis of faith in “The Third Miracle,” a flawed drama offering a rare look at the Catholic Church’s canonization process.

Harris plays Father Frank Shore, a “postulator,” or clerical detective, whose job is to investigate miracles attributed to candidates for sainthood.

As the movie opens, Frank is living on the streets of Chicago as a lay person, his spirit in disarray after he exposed one candidate as a suicide — an episode that left him with the nickname “The Miracle Killer.”

Frank’s superiors track him down and hand him a new job. In a poor parish, a deceased immigrant woman is being credited with a bleeding statue of the Virgin Mary, as well as the miraculous cure of a girl suffering from a brain tumor.

Father Frank very reluctantly tracks down the girl, who has grown up into a prostitute (Barbara Sukowa), as well as the dead woman’s agnostic daughter (Anne Heche), with whom he is drawn into a none-too-convincing romance.

The skeptical cleric comes to believe in the miracles, but needs proof of a third one. He learns that during World War II, the woman lived in an Austrian village where the Allied bombing abruptly stopped — after she prayed to a statue of the Virgin Mary.

The movie climaxes with a trial that pits Father Frank against a cardinal (a hammy Armin Mueller-Stahl) who serves as a devil’s advocate against the canonization — and it’s here where the movie self-destructs with a mind-boggling coincidence.

Agnieszka Holland (“A Little Princess”), who previously directed Harris in “To Kill a Priest” (in which he played a Polish secret police officer) lays out the story at a rather leisurely pace. It’s not terribly clear when it’s taking place; Heche’s fake-fur-trimmed coats suggest the 1970s.

“The Third Miracle” is worth seeing mainly for Harris and its unusual subject matter.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy