He did it! Jaime Lannister finally slept with a woman he’s not related to on “Game of Thrones.” And it was great — until suddenly it wasn’t.
Spoilers below for Season 8 Episode 4.
Jaime (Nikolaj Coster-Waldau) and Brienne (Gwendoline Christine) have been the show’s longest-running “will they or won’t they” couple. Over the course of seven seasons (since they met in Season 2), they’ve progressed from enemies to friends to ambiguous love interests who are each too psychologically damaged to admit they’re in love, until now. The two knights finally consummate their relationship in this episode. It’s a great moment … until it ends badly when Jaime leaves and Brienne is distraught.
WTF? Is this suddenly “Buffy the Vampire Slayer”? Jaime’s had the show’s best redemption arc. Did having sex with Brienne make him lose his soul?
Yes and no. It certainly seems out of character for the guy who famously said “the things I do for love” to, um, abandon the woman he loves.
But there are two possibilities here. The shift in Jaime comes when he hears that one of the dragons has been shot. So Daenerys (Emilia Clarke) is weakened, and maybe can’t be counted on to take out Cersei herself. His face falls when he hears that news, and he seems deep in thought. He then lashes out at Brienne when she asks him to stay by appealing to his nature as a “good man.” He goes on a rant about the terrible things he’s done, all for his twin and ex-lover, Cersei (Lena Headey).
So one possibility is that he has a deeper plan to take Cersei out, since clearly nobody else can be trusted with the job. But since he thinks it’s a suicide mission, he wants to turn Brienne against him. It echoes his brother Tyrion (Peter Dinklage) in Season 4, when he tried to send his lover Shae (Sibel Kikelli) away from King’s Landing in order to save her life. He ended up being cruel to her in his breakup speech, so that he could be sure she’d really leave (and then she still didn’t).























So it’s possible Jaime is pulling a Tyrion and not being truthful on purpose. Otherwise maybe she’d want to come with him, and she’d be in danger.
It’s also possible that his redemption journey hasn’t been a straight line. He still has a healthy dose of self-loathing from living with years of internalized shame as the Kingslayer, being misunderstood and judged the most harshly for his best and bravest action. It’s within reason that his self-loathing is now manifesting in a tragically misguided way. He does love Brienne — and so leaving her is a thing that he’s doing for love.
As Jaime once said, you don’t get to choose whom you love. But as he’s shown time and time again with his actions, you do get to choose how you act and what you do about it. And as much as we love Jaime, as much as he’s a man of honor, he doesn’t always act in the best way. That’s completely on brand for this tragic man.
While it might be disappointing to internet shippers, as Ramsey Bolton (Iwan Rheon) once said, “if you think this has a happy ending, you haven’t been paying attention.” Happily ever afters are rare indeed on “Game of Thrones.” Still, don’t let it diminish the beauty of Jaime and Brienne’s journey over the past seven seasons.
“Game of Thrones” Season 8 airs Sunday nights on HBO.



