Logo
Chef Jesse PerezHandoutChef Jesse PerezHandout

I’ll admit it. I love Chipotle. I eat it at least once a week. Hell — full admission — I even own a few shares of stock.

So, when Óxido, a new fast/casual restaurant with a menu very similar to Chipotle’s, opened in the Flatiron last week, I was immediately intrigued.

Chef Jesse Perez, a James-Beard-Award-nominee from San Antonio, is the man behind Óxido, and he’s committed to bringing Mexican flavors that are at once traditional and modern to the choose-your-own-toppings concept.

And while there’s currently just one Óxido location (18 W. 23rd St.), Perez and his business partners — entrepreneur Shmilly Gruenstein and Daihwan Choi, who brought the first Pinkberry to New York City — are committed to expanding by year’s end.

Should my darling Chipotle be worried? Here, a side-by-side comparison:

Menu

Chipotle vs. ÓxidoHandout/Brian ZakChipotle vs. ÓxidoHandout/Brian Zak

Chipotle: The lunch-hour favorite features burritos, bowls and salads with your choice of proteins, rice, beans, cheese and salsas for $8.27 to $8.96. Tacos are available for $2.99 to $3.22 each.

Óxido: The newcomer features burritos, bowls and tacos with your choice of proteins, rice, beans, cheese and salsas for $8.50 to $9.15. No salad option is currently available — though Perez notes you can make a bowl with lots of lettuce, there just isn’t dressing available — and tacos must be ordered in pairs.

The whole burrito (or taco)

Chipotle: Chipotle’s belly-bomb burritos have a tendency toward congealed rice-cheese wads that are at once delicious and disgusting. The beans can be a bit dry.

On the taco front, Chipotle does have a small advantage, in that it offers three tortilla options — soft flour, soft corn and crispy corn.

Chipotle’s and Óxido’s tacos go head-to-head.Brian Zak (2)Chipotle’s and Óxido’s tacos go head-to-head.Brian Zak (2)

Óxido: Óxido’s cheese is grated in shorter, thicker strands that help it disperse evenly in the burrito, while the basmati rice has a bit more integrity than Chipotle’s shorter grains.

The charro pinto beans are made with bacon — unlike Chipotle’s vegetarian pinto beans — and are uniquely flavorful and indulgent.

The only tortilla option for tacos is soft corn — tasty but some may miss the crunch option.

Proteins

Chipotle square off in Óxido proteinsBrian Zak (2)Chipotle square off in Óxido proteinsBrian Zak (2)

Chipotle: Lightly spiced cubes of chicken and steak or shredded beef are as familiar as mom’s home-cooking; all of the chicken and most of the beef options are raised without hormones or antibiotics.

Due to supply issues and a commitment to quality meat, pork carnitas are not available in one-third of the locations at any given time.

The vegan-braised tofu — “Sofritas” — packs plenty of flavor but has a mealy, rubbery texture that won’t convert this carnivore.

Óxido: Óxido’s chicken and steak chunks are more boldly flavored, irregularly shaped and tender than Chipotle’s.

And they have carnitas day-in and day-out! The proteins seem more authentic — the steak actually tastes like carne asada — but also slightly greasier and less healthy.

Óxido’s rich, red-chile mushrooms are perfectly cooked and blow Chipotle’s “Sofritas” out of the tortilla.

Salsas

Salsa offerings at Chipotle, left and Óxido, rightBrian Zak (2)Salsa offerings at Chipotle, left and Óxido, rightBrian Zak (2)

Chipotle: Four familiar friends — roasted corn, tomatillo-green chili, spicy tomatillo-red chili and a tomato salsa whose tomatoes manage to miraculously taste fresh and be bright red nearly every day of the year.

Óxido: Óxido’s condiment clearly put it on top. There are six salsa offerings in the traditional sense — from chile de arbol to fire-roasted tomato — plus a creamy chipotle crema.

There’s also a queso sauce and a corn relish that’s far sweeter than Chipotle’s corny offering and has a bit of cotija cheese mixed in to taste like Mexican street corn.

While none pack as much heat as Chipotle’s spiciest offering, Perez says he is working on a “killer sauce” with spicy habanero.

Chips and Guacamole

Guacamole at Chipotle, left, is pricier than at Óxido, right.Handout/Brian ZakGuacamole at Chipotle, left, is pricier than at Óxido, right.Handout/Brian Zak

Chipotle: A healthy scoop of Chipotle’s fresh green stuff is one of life’s simple pleasures, but it will cost you $2.30. The white-corn tortilla chips are certainly not low-cal, but in the world of Mexican-restaurant chips, they’re relatively light and don’t leave greasy stains on the bag.

Óxido: Óxido’s avocado offering is noticeably more citrusy and bright, with a bit of pico de gallo mixed in. It costs just $.95 to add it to your order, but it’s not applied with the same joyous excess as at Chipotle. The extra-thick yellow-corn chips are heavily seasoned with smoked paprika and cayenne — tasty but heavy, man, real heavy.

And the winner is…

I’m not going to abandon my conveniently located old friend. It tastes a bit healthier and more suitable for consuming multiple time per week but…

Oxido’s bolder, more authentic flavors and amazing salsa selection put it out in front.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy