Logo
MediaMedia

Scott Pelley’s brazen attack on the new boss of “60 Minutes” has divided staffers at CBS News, with some insiders branding his behavior “bullying” and “grandstanding” — and another reckoning it was “a set-up,” The Post has learned. 

Pelley laced into Nick Bilton, the new executive producer of “60 Minutes,” on Monday during a meet-and-greet with staffers, calling out the boss’s lack of TV experience, challenging his vision and telling him he would “never be welcomed here.”

“What did he accomplish?” one CBS source said of Pelley’s explosive attack. “He embarrassed the company and the leadership.”

A day after the confrontation, Pelley met with CBS top brass in order to “find a path forward,” according to Puck News.


  Scott Pelley’s brazen attack on the new boss of “60 Minutes” has divided staffers at CBS News, sources said. 60 Minutes / YouTube Scott Pelley’s brazen attack on the new boss of “60 Minutes” has divided staffers at CBS News, sources said. 60 Minutes / YouTube

But following the meeting, it became clear that path will end up with Pelley exiting CBS, Puck said. 

“Scott Pelley had a meeting with CBS News leadership at 5pm ET to discuss a path forward after his protest in 60 Minutes all-hands,” Puck’s Dylan Byers wrote in a post on X. “The two sides did not find common ground and it now seems likely he will either resign or be fired, though neither has happened yet.”

CBS News declined to comment on Puck’s report.

One media exec said of Pelley’s likely exit: “It’s about leadership. You can’t lead a place where you’re told you aren’t welcome. You can’t lead a place where the #1 anchor says you have no qualifications and have wrecked the place.”

The source added that CBS News editor-in-chief Bari Weiss has “lost the confidence” of the staff amid her plans to overhaul the show. 

Network sources said Bilton and Weiss had tried to speak privately ahead of the meeting with Pelley — who was fuming about the network’s firing of “60 Minutes” correspondents Sharyn Alfonsi and Cecilia Vega, executive producer Tanya Simon and other top producers last week.

“This was a set-up. This was Scott going off for show,” the insider opined. “This was just a show. He wants to stand up for journalism and maybe get fired but what does it change?”

A second source agreed that Pelley’s tactics were “problematic,” noting that the correspondent should have met with Weiss or Bilton to at least hear them out.

“That grandstanding thing is insane. It’s third-grade, playground bullying stuff,” the source said. “This is not the way you conduct yourself.”

“You’re not taking down a dictator or someone who has committed war crimes,” the source added. “You’re not interviewing Saddam Hussein. It was a little bit overkill.”


  New “60 Minutes'” executive producer Nick Bilton had a heated exchange with Pelley on Monday during a staff meeting. Getty Images New “60 Minutes'” executive producer Nick Bilton had a heated exchange with Pelley on Monday during a staff meeting. Getty Images

It remains unclear how CBS intends to react to Pelley’s tirade. As previously reported by The Post, Pelley has another year left on his contract and makes around $5 million a year.

Sources speculated that the network is likely loath to pay Pelley $5 million to quit. Ultimately, the decision rests with David Ellison, the CEO of CBS owner Paramount Skydance.

A rep for the company declined to comment.

“Most people are perplexed in the building. There are people here who think ’60 Minutes’ is arrogant,” the source said.


  Pelley slammed CBS News boss Bari Weiss, claiming she was “murdering ’60 Minutes,’” and that she “was brought in to kill it and is doing exactly that.” Getty Images for The Free Press Pelley slammed CBS News boss Bari Weiss, claiming she was “murdering ’60 Minutes,’” and that she “was brought in to kill it and is doing exactly that.” Getty Images for The Free Press

CBS News journalists sometimes feel like second-class citizens, according to the source, who noted that the show ignores pitches from non-“60 Minutes” producers and dislikes non-“60 Minutes” journalists appearing on the show.

“Their arrogance is beyond reproach,” the source said. “But at the same time, CBS people understand that they’ll be affected by Bari Weiss too, and it’s like, who do you hate more, ’60 Minutes’ or Bari Weiss and her people?”

Weiss has made a slew of bold moves in her eight-month tenure, including shaking up “CBS Evening News” and installing former “CBS Mornings” co-host Tony Dokoupil as anchor. She also shuttered the century-old CBS News Radio and brought in Bilton, a former New York Times tech columnist with a handful of documentary producing credits, to lead “60 Minutes.”


  “60 Minutes” correspondent Lesley Stahl (left) with (from right) Tanya Simon, Cecilia Vega and Sharyn Alfonsi, who were all let go last week. CBS via Getty Images “60 Minutes” correspondent Lesley Stahl (left) with (from right) Tanya Simon, Cecilia Vega and Sharyn Alfonsi, who were all let go last week. CBS via Getty Images

  Sources speculated that Paramount Skydance CEO David Ellison will ultimately decide Pelley’s fate. AFP via Getty Images Sources speculated that Paramount Skydance CEO David Ellison will ultimately decide Pelley’s fate. AFP via Getty Images

Pelley claimed in his rant that Weiss was “murdering ’60 Minutes,’” and that she “was brought in to kill it and is doing exactly that,” while adding that “she has no qualifications for her job.”

Pelley added that Bilton has “slender” qualifications for his new position, and demanded to know why the correspondent’s colleagues had been fired. In a heated back-and forth, Bilton said he had nothing to do with the cuts, and later told Pelley he wasn’t going to be “intimidated” before abruptly ending the meeting.

As previously reported, the room “erupted” in applause after Bilton left — a bad sign, according to a former CBS News exec, who said it meant that the staffers in the room are “afraid” to speak their minds in front of leadership.

The person said it should be essential for journalists to be able to have a debate and be heard without fear of retribution.

Late Tuesday, Breaker Media reported that CBS CEO George Cheeks had advised Weiss against blowing up the respected, profitable and highly rated “60 Minutes.”

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy