Logo

Bryce Harper sent a young fan home with a souvenir he wasn’t expecting after he gave umpire Angel Hernandez a tongue-lashing he won’t soon forget. 

Hernandez, one of the most criticized umpires in Major League Baseball, made a questionable strike-three call on Harper’s check swing during Thursday’s game between the Phillies and Pirates at Citizens Bank Park, a 3-2 Pittsburgh win. 

“Angel in the middle of something again,” Harper after the game. “It’s just every year. It’s the same story, same thing.”

Both the catcher, Jason Delay, and the home plate umpire, James Hoye, appealed to Hernandez, who was manning third, to make the call.

That’s when Hernandez ruled that Harper had gone around with his swing and had struck out, though it did not appear Harper had gone around. 

The call instantly infuriated Harper, who charged up the third baseline to scream at the ump.

Harper was only a third of the way there when Hernandez threw him out of the game. 

Harper continued to angrily speed toward third and argue the call before finally reaching Hernandez and getting in his face.

Phillies third base coach Dusty Wathan stepped in to try to keep Harper in line, and manager Rob Thomson was able to get Harper to head back to the dugout. 

A visibly frustrated Harper walked back to the dugout, and before walking down the steps and heading back to the clubhouse, the Phillies star chucked his helmet into the stands. 


  Phillies’ Bryce Harper argues a call during the third inning of a baseball game against the Pirates. AP Phillies’ Bryce Harper argues a call during the third inning of a baseball game against the Pirates. AP

“It just seems like every single time he is on the base or behind the plate, there’s always an issue. It’s almost 100 percent of the time,” analyst Ruben Amaro Jr. said on the NBC Sports Philadelphia broadcast. 

A young fan, a 10-year-old named Hayden, caught the helmet that Harper threw into the crowd and was seen wearing it with a big smile on his face later during the game. 

Harper even signed the helmet, per KYWN.

“It’s just not right,” Harper said of the call. “It’s just the reaction of, I should be on first base. I’m grinding as hard as I can in the batter’s box. These games, everyone talks about, oh, they don’t mean that much. But they do. For each stat, each game, winning games, a winning mentality, everything. All these at-bats matter. We don’t play this game forever.”


  Bryce Harper is ejected for arguing his strikeout call with umpire Angel Hernandez (R) and umpire James Hoye (L) in front of manager Rob Thomson during the third inning against the Pirates. USA TODAY Sports via Reuters Con Bryce Harper is ejected for arguing his strikeout call with umpire Angel Hernandez (R) and umpire James Hoye (L) in front of manager Rob Thomson during the third inning against the Pirates. USA TODAY Sports via Reuters Con

  Bryce Harper throws his helmet into the stands. USA TODAY Sports via Reuters Con Bryce Harper throws his helmet into the stands. USA TODAY Sports via Reuters Con

Major league umpires have faced increased scrutiny this season over their calls, but Hernandez has a long history of being called out by players and managers. 

Last month, a federal appeals court refused to reinstate a racial discrimination case that Hernandez had filed against MLB.

He originally filed the suit in 2017, alleging that he was being discriminated against since he had not been assigned to call a World Series since 2005. 

In 2021, a district court granted MLB a summary judgment, and the 2nd Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals upheld that decision in August.

— With AP

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy