Only one more managerial situation is basically certain to change, and that is the unique case of 2023 Manager of the Year Skip Schumaker and the Marlins, who agreed to drop the 2025 team option on Schumaker’s deal at his request. That’ll be the Marlins’ loss.
Scott Servais’ ouster in Seattle on Thursday made it two managers fired so far, following the White Sox and Pedro Grifol, and it’ll still be a surprise if everyone else besides Schumaker stays. Managing isn’t exactly known for job security.
Here are some interesting scenarios (and a few thoughts on potential replacements):
Hot Seat (likely leaving)
1. Schumaker
He’ll find a better opportunity elsewhere, if not immediately, then soon.
Manager Skip Schumaker #45 of the Miami Marlins argues with umpire Gabe Morales. Getty Images
2. Grady Sizemore, White Sox (interim)
Sizemore is likely to stay in some role as he’s beloved by players, but the team plans to go outside. A.J. Pierzynski has been mentioned as a candidate. Jim Thome would be great but he’s busy with his son’s high school career. Rangers bench coach Will Venable is a more likely candidate.
Warm Seat
3. John Schneider, Blue Jays
It feels like honchos Mark Shapiro and Ross Atkins will survive despite the 2024 disaster. If a fall guy is sought, Schneider may be it, especially after their big disagreement following the Jose Berrios early playoff exit.
Blue Jays manager John Schneider (14) relieves pitcher Yariel Rodriguez. Dan Hamilton-USA TODAY SportsPlayoff Pressure
4. Aaron Boone, Yankees
The general consensus is he needs to win a playoff round, but his bosses do love him.
Yankees manager Aaron Boone walks back to the dugout after arguing a call with home plate umpire Tripp Gibson. JASON SZENES FOR THE NEW YORK POST5. Dave Roberts, Dodgers
The pressure seems real after big winter buys, but Roberts is outstanding and they again have MLB’s best record.
A Bit of Heat
6. Oliver Marmol, Cardinals
It’s an average team playing average baseball, an improvement. Are front office changes also possible? Two great potential manager replacements: Cardinals legend Yadier Molina and Schumaker.
Cardinals manager Oliver Marmol walks back from the mound after making a pitching change. AP7. Derek Shelton, Pirates
Beloved by bosses, which explains regular extensions. Likely staying again.
8. David Bell, Reds
They’re underachieving, but he, too, is a favorite of higher-ups.
Situation Questions
9. Bud Black, Rockies
They’ve said there won’t be any word until after the year, but it’s believed he has tenure unless he prefers a lesser role.
10. Bruce Bochy, Rangers
The best October manager ever certainly isn’t in trouble. He has a year to go and didn’t seem to love semi-retirement, but with GM Chris Young still not extended after months of talks, it’s worth wondering.
11. Brian Snitker, Braves
He’s doing very well to stay in a playoff spot, but folks see him walking away after his contract expires next year.
