Logo

It’s a good thing for Shohei Ohtani that scouts, managers and coaches don’t have an AL Rookie of the Year vote.

In a Post poll of voices from those MLB positions, not only did the Angels’ Ohtani, a rare two-way performer, not win, but Yankees third baseman Miguel Andujar was a unanimous selection.

The BBWAA kicks off its award season Monday night with the AL and NL Rookie of the Year award winners. Two voters from each AL city will determine whether Ohtani or Andujar wins. Gleyber Torres joined them in the final three, but it has long been viewed as a two-player race, even if a scout in close contact with the AL had Torres second and Ohtani third.

The support for Andujar was strong and also unanimous, but that doesn’t guarantee a victory.

“Impacted his team all year,’’ said a scout who saw a lot of the 23-year-old Andujar, who took advantage of Brandon Drury being sidelined early in the season with migraine headaches and blurred vision.

Andujar was so good and consistent at the plate that those polled overlooked his 15 errors in 149 games, which tied for the fourth-most in baseball with the Giants’ Evan Longoria and Phillies’ Maikel Franco. Rafael Devers of the Red Sox led baseball with 24 miscues.

Miguel AndujarPaul J. BereswillMiguel AndujarPaul J. Bereswill

Andujar led all major league rookies in hits (170), doubles (47), extra-base hits (76) and multi-hit games (53). He tied for the rookie lead in homers (27) and was second in runs (83) and batting average (.297).

If Andujar wins, he will be the second straight Yankee to cop the award after Aaron Judge won it in 2017. Over the years, the Yankees have had nine AL winners but never back-to-back.

Until a tear in his right UCL was discovered in early June, Ohtani was a rare two-way star in the making. He went 4-1 with a 3.10 ERA in nine starts with June 6 being the last until a 2 ¹/₃-inning stint Sept. 2.

After missing about a month, Ohtani returned to being a DH, and in 70 games, he batted .283 with 16 homers, 41 RBIs and a .935 OPS.

Torres, who didn’t make his major league debut until April 22, hit .271 with 24 homers, 77 RBIs and a .899 OPS.

“[I would vote for] Andujar, but I think Ohtani will get it,’’ a team executive said.

If Ohtani, who chose the Angels over the Yankees and others when he was a free agent last offseason, had continued to pitch and hit as he did in the first two months, the award would be his, said a manager.

“He wins it in a slam dunk if he doesn’t get hurt,” the manager said. “But the rookie of the year is Andujar. I know he had some defensive issues, but look at the overall year. He played every day and put up numbers and played in a pennant race.”

A coach pointed to Andujar picking up the slack for injuries (Aaron Judge and Didi Gregorius) and underperformance (Gary Sanchez and Greg Bird).

“He was a constant for them. He was the guy that stayed healthy and produced at a consistent level with many big hits,” the coach said of Andujar, who batted .294 with eight homers and 64 RBIs and posted a .916 OPS with runners in scoring position. “I know his defense wasn’t Gold Glove-caliber, but he was a big part of their 100-win season. To do it in New York in a playoff race, that is more impactful than what Ohtani did.”

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy