Pete Alonso’s two-year reign as Home Run Derby champion has come to a close.

After defeating Ronald Acuna Jr. in the first round, Alonso faced a more formidable foe in the second round as he went toe-to-toe with rookie sensation Julio Rodríguez. The two-time defending champion crushed another 23 home runs, but the valiant effort ultimately wasn’t enough to beat Rodríguez’s 31 blasts.

Although Alonso’s improbable three-pete has now been squandered, the 27-year-old has much to look forward to as the All-Star festivities continue. Perhaps he will get a chance at redemption in tomorrow’s main event, which features a brand new Home Run Derby if the contest reaches extra-innings.