Logo

The Yankees and Guardians square off in the ALDS starting on Tuesday night. The Post’s baseball experts give their predictions on how they think the best-of-five series will play out.

Jon Heyman 

The Yankees-Guardians series is a study in contrasts: Big market versus small, rich versus poor, veterans versus newbies, power versus production. But the biggest contrast is in the bullpen: Cleveland’s is the best and the Yankees’ is currently a mess.

Prediction: Guardians in 5

Greg Joyce

The series should feature some strong pitching, which puts a bigger spotlight on the offenses scratching across runs. In October, that usually means hitting homers, in which only one of these teams specializes.

Prediction: Yankees in 4 

Dan Martin 

This Cleveland team is young, athletic and playing well. But the Yankees have generally feasted on AL Central opponents in the playoffs and this year should be no different.

Prediction: Yankees in 4


  The Yankees preparing for the ALDS against the Guardians on Oct. 10, 2022. Charles Wenzelberg / New York Post The Yankees preparing for the ALDS against the Guardians on Oct. 10, 2022. Charles Wenzelberg / New York Post

Ian O’Connor 

The best home-run hitting team in the sport versus the team that struck out fewer times than any other. I’ll go with power over contact.

Prediction: Yankees in 4 

Mark W. Sanchez 

The Yankees’ power is a good counter to the Guardians’ excellent pitching. One or two swings will change games. Cleveland’s contact-based approach won’t work against a solid Yankees defense.

Prediction: Yankees in 4 

Joel Sherman 

The Yankees have home field plus depth of talent and playoff experience.

Prediction: Yankees in 4


  Jose Ramirez (center), Amed Rosario (right) and Oscar Gonzalez work out at Yankee Stadium on Oct. 10, 2022. AP Jose Ramirez (center), Amed Rosario (right) and Oscar Gonzalez work out at Yankee Stadium on Oct. 10, 2022. AP

Mike Vaccaro 

The Guardians are feisty and fun to watch and they are brilliantly managed. The Yankees, however, are simply better in every facet, and they sure do love feasting on the AL Central in the playoffs.

Prediction: Yankees in 4

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy