Logo

Former Knicks first-round pick Jerrod Mustaf, who was embroiled in a murder controversy during his career, died Monday on his 55th birthday, according to the Baltimore Sun

The cause of death is not yet known, per the report. 

The Knicks drafted Mustaf with the 17th pick in the 1990 NBA Draft out of Maryland. 


  Jerrod Mustaf before the 1990 season. NBAE via Getty Images Jerrod Mustaf before the 1990 season. NBAE via Getty Images

The power forward averaged 4.3 points and 2.7 rebounds across 62 games (five starts) in his rookie campaign for a 39-43 Knicks team that the eventual champion Bulls swept in the first round of the 1991 playoffs.

That offseason, the Suns acquired him, Trent Tucker and two second-round picks in exchange for Xavier McDaniel. 

Mustaf played three seasons with Phoenix, averaging just 3.9 points and 2.4 rebounds across 117 games. 

“Nothing about Phoenix was a good fit for me,” Mustaf told Sports Illustrated. 


  Jerrod Mustaf played for the Knicks for one season. NBAE via Getty Images Jerrod Mustaf played for the Knicks for one season. NBAE via Getty Images

During his time there, Mustaf found himself engulfed in controversy after being accused of having his pregnant girlfriend, Althea Hayes, murdered.

Hayes was shot in the head on July 22, 1993, while three months pregnant with Mustaf’s child, according to the News & Record

Mustaf’s cousin, LaVonnie Wooten, was convicted of first-degree murder and received a life sentence without parole, according to the Washington Times, but both the prosecution and defense claimed Mustaf masterminded the murder since he wanted Hayes to have an abortion, per the report.


  Jerrod Mustaf during a game against the Rockets. NBAE via Getty Images Jerrod Mustaf during a game against the Rockets. NBAE via Getty Images

  Mustaf’s alleged girlfriend Althea Hayes ABC 15 Arizona Mustaf’s alleged girlfriend Althea Hayes ABC 15 Arizona

The ex-NBAer is alleged by Hayes’ family to have offered $5,000 for her to not have the baby, per a Tucson Citizen report. 

The Suns bought out the remaining two years and $3.8 million remaining on Mustaf’s contract in 1994 following the murder, per The New York Times. 

Mustaf was never charged with any crime despite the allegations, and he claimed he did not know that Hayes was pregnant, per the outlet.


  Mustaf starred at Maryland before joining the Knicks. NBAE via Getty Images Mustaf starred at Maryland before joining the Knicks. NBAE via Getty Images

He settled out of court with Hayes’ family in 1998 following a wrongful death lawsuit by Hayes’ parents, according to the Washington Times.

He told Sports Illustrated that the accusations against him were “totally unfair” and helped keep him out of the league. 

“Whether I was blackballed,” he told the publication, “isn’t even a question.” 

K.C. Scull, the Phoenix prosecutor who had been assigned to the case, told Sports Illustrated that it pains him that he could not take it to trail. 


  Mustaf played the final three years of his career with the Suns. NBAE via Getty Images Mustaf played the final three years of his career with the Suns. NBAE via Getty Images

“It’s one of my biggest regrets that I wasn’t allowed to try this case,” he said. 

Mustaf dealt with further legal issues when he was charged with second-degree assault in 2001, according to the Washington Times. 

He also allegedly assaulted and threatened a pregnant girlfriend during his college days and, years later, fired a gun while in the presence of his pregnant girlfriend, per Sports Illustrated. 

Over the duration of his four-year NBA career, Mustaf averaged 4.0 points and 2.5 rebounds spanning 179 NBA games before transitioning to an international career. 

The North Carolina native previously had averaged 16.6 points and 7.7 rebounds across two collegiate seasons with the Terrapins, including a team-best 18.5 points and 7.7 rebounds in his sophomore season in 1989-90. 

“Jerrod was a very talented big man who was very skilled in all phases of the game,” former Maryland coach Gary Williams told the Baltimore Sun in a statement. “He played one season for me, which was my first year at Maryland. … He was an important member of the Maryland basketball family.” 

Later in life, Mustaf immersed himself in charitable work following his playing career. 

He became the executive director of Take Charge, a nonprofit program for youths. 

“I will do whatever I can to clear my name to continue to live a meaningful life,” Mustaf said in 1996 while attempting to make the SuperSonics, according to the Seattle Times. “I want to improve relations between blacks and whites and Jews and others, and I think I can.”

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy