Logo

An unpatriotic story is percolating.

A man is suing the Patriots Hall of Fame for allegedly causing up to $1 million of damage to a flag signed by Tom Brady that he had loaned to the museum.

According to Yahoo Sports, a fan named Daniel Vitale loaned an American flag that flew over Foxboro Stadium in 2001, Brady’s first year as the Patriots’ starter. It was signed by Brady months later — and the autograph was authenticated. There is also a patch sewn into the flag commemorating the fact that this was the last season the Patriots played at their old stadium in Foxboro, Mass., before moving to Gillette Stadium.

The autographed flag was loaned to the Patriots Hall of Fame last year.

Vitale claims in his lawsuit that when he agreed to loan the flag to them, he was assured by the museum’s curator, Kurt Evans, that it would be displayed “using accepted professional library and museum techniques and standards.”


  A fan named Daniel Vitale is suing the Patriots Hall of Fame for allegedly causing up to $1 million of damage to his flag signed by Tom Brady. Twitter / Pats Flag Gate A fan named Daniel Vitale is suing the Patriots Hall of Fame for allegedly causing up to $1 million of damage to his flag signed by Tom Brady. Twitter / Pats Flag Gate

The plaintiff said he was repeatedly assured by Evans that the memorabilia would be handled with care, and therefore declined to insist on insurance.

According to the suit, Vitale and his fiancée went to go see the flag late last year, but it was not on display. However, they noticed a faded autograph on a different item.


  Tom Brady in the 2001-02 AFC Championship Game. Getty Images Tom Brady in the 2001-02 AFC Championship Game. Getty Images

“I know, I’ve been telling them for years that they need to switch out the lighting and glass. It is not the right stuff for this type of display,” Evans allegedly told Vitale.

This past January, Vitale was allegedly informed by Evans that the autograph sustained “slight fading.”

A photo shared by Vitale indicates that the fading was more than slight.

Vitale is seeking unspecified damages but claims that the Patriots Hall of Fame breached its contract with him and is guilty of negligence in causing up to $1 million in damage to the memorabilia.

Brady played for the Patriots from 2000 through 2019, winning six Super Bowls and three MVPs with the franchise before leaving in free agency for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy