Logo

Hallelujah: City Comptroller Scott Stringer has gotten religion on the sham that is Mayor Bill de Blasio’s bloated Renewal schools program.

In an April 5 letter, Stringer demands that new Chancellor Richard Carranza determine if the mayor’s $600 million boondoggle is effective. After all, he writes, the absence of “consistent progress across all Renewal schools suggests the need for a more thorough review of the program’s components and their overall impact.”

Stringer wants the Department of Education to detail its spending on each of those components: longer school days, teacher training, “leadership coaches” and consultants.

On the other hand, he also complains that the decisions to close a few Renewal schools are “breeding needless distrust in communities.” Is he hoping to tap that distrust in a future mayoral run?

It’s not clear if Carranza saw the letter before he told Chalkbeat last week that the Renewal program lacks a single clear “theory of action” and noted that simply providing a package of social services (as the city does by making each Renewal a “community school”) “doesn’t cause academic improvement.”

On the merits, Carranza should junk Renewal now, and move to close those schools. After all, the benchmarks they’re supposed to meet are a joke — and even ones that fall short have remained open.

The program isn’t really about turning around failed schools, but merely pretending to.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy