Logo

At Brooklyn’s James Madison High School, new JV football players face a ritual — the older players surround them, de-pant them and softly hit them.

One parent tells The Post it’s been going on for years. He shared a video of one of the incidents, where the “victim” was laughing the entire time.

Except this year, one student who was de-panted told his parents, and it set off a firestorm. Some players face criminal charges and have been suspended from school. The coach has been fired. And the football season is on the verge of being canceled

What a stunning overreaction. What a terrible lesson. 

Times have changed, we understand. Hazing, no matter how light-hearted, is no longer acceptable, and too often gets out of hand. But the answer to that is: Ban hazing.

Suspending the students for something generations have done before? Cancel football games and punish the entire team for these actions? Have we lost all perspective?

And most ridiculously: Calling the cops over this?

This is a teachable moment for kids on the team, and at the school more broadly, if ever there was one. 

Suspend the pantsters for a game. Have them write essays explaining why what they did was wrong. 

Have the coach give them a talking to, making clear that even if it’s all fun and games, it has to stop and that respect for your teammates is as big a part of athletic life as scoring touchdowns.  

Maybe even throw in a little community service time. 

But rushing to criminalize them is insane. 

Especially since it sure sounds like this was very likely a team-wide roughhousing game, of a kind extremely common among adolescent boys. 

Not a violent gang assault, a robbery, a shooting or a real sex crime. 

And yes, Madison has had major problems in the past. 

The school is being sued for an actual alleged assault by a former football coach, who viciously slammed a kid’s head into a wall and was correctly later arrested and charged with felonies. 

But a theatrical crackdown against an entire team of kids — who are guilty largely of just being kids — in the service of bolstering administrators’ rep to help win a lawsuit seems supremely ill-considered. 

Kids will be kids. They need to learn to be adults. 

Ruining their lives over trivialities won’t help them do that. 

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy