Logo

Brooklyn Supreme Court Judge Bruce Balter yesterday denied a Transport Workers Union request that would have paved the way for future transit shutdowns.

Good for the judge – who showed respect for the law and for common sense.

The TWU had asked Balter to restore its privilege of collecting dues via deductions from members’ paychecks – a right it lost thanks to its illegal strike of Christmas 2005.

The loss of the “check-off” was to last at least through last August, when the union could regain the right only by pledging never to strike again. That was a reasonable compromise: After all, public-sector unions got the privilege in exchange for their strikes being formally outlawed by the 1967 Taylor Law.

But for Toussaint – who maintains the 2005 shutdown was his union’s “finest hour” – the law has little meaning.

His statement to Balter fell far short of pledging never to strike again; instead, in the judge’s words, it “merely parrots the statutory language.”

It’s worth noting that the judge’s wise ruling came despite the Spitzer administration’s kow-tow to the TWU.

New MTA chief Elliot Sander formally urged restoration of the privilege, and Gov. Spitzer himself favored the TWU’s recovering its check-off powers.

This would have allowed the TWU to continue showing open contempt for the law, demonstrating that illegal strikes pay after all.

The 7 million New Yorkers who ride the subways and buses daily can thank Judge Balter for doing his best to discourage future job actions.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy