Logo

A New Jersey home built for Macy’s heir Herbert Straus in the 1920s is set to hit the market for $1.57 million.

This will be the first time since 1953 that prospective buyers have the chance to own the property, The Post has learned.

Straus’s father, Macy’s co-owner and US Congressman Isidor Straus, perished on the Titanic with his wife, Ida, who refused a seat in a lifeboat to remain at her husband’s side while the ship sunk.

Originally built on 143 acres, the estate — located in Middletown — has since been converted from a dairy barn.

Now standing on 13 acres, the property, known as Cobble Close Farm, features five private residences, considered a co-op, and is French Norman style built with materials transported from Europe — including stucco and ceramic tile.

The property is surrounded by fountains, gardens, a pool and lawns bordered by Greco-Roman statues, and an orangery


  An aerial shot of the 13-acre estate. Resources Real Estate An aerial shot of the 13-acre estate. Resources Real Estate

  The estate is located in Middletown, New Jersey. Resources Real Estate The estate is located in Middletown, New Jersey. Resources Real Estate

  The outside colonnade. Resources Real Estate The outside colonnade. Resources Real Estate

  The solarium. Resources Real Estate The solarium. Resources Real Estate

  The solarium seen at night. Resources Real Estate The solarium seen at night. Resources Real Estate

Spanning nearly 5,000 square feet, the main home features a solarium, a parlor, a dining room and an adjacent three-bedroom apartment.

Other features include a high-ceiling great room with exposed beams, three fireplaces, two garages, a finished basement, and three private and walled gardens.

The living room overlooks the cobblestoned courtyard.


  The library. Resources Real Estate The library. Resources Real Estate

  The kitchen leads to the solarium. Resources Real Estate The kitchen leads to the solarium. Resources Real Estate

  The main hall on the first floor. Resources Real Estate The main hall on the first floor. Resources Real Estate

  The bar. Resources Real Estate The bar. Resources Real Estate

  One of four bedrooms. Resources Real Estate One of four bedrooms. Resources Real Estate

Meanwhile, the primary bedroom features its own walled courtyard, and comes with a fountain and lounge chairs.

One one side of the estate is the Navesink Country Club. On the other are horse stables and pastures made for trail riding.

1 of 10
The formal dining room.
The formal dining room. Resources Real Estate
The great room.
The great room. Resources Real Estate
Advertisement
The patio.
The patio. Resources Real Estate
Another bedroom.
Another bedroom.Resources Real Estate
The upstairs hall.
The upstairs hall. Resources Real Estate
Advertisement
The attic.
The attic. Resources Real Estate
The library holds a woodburning fireplace.
The library holds a woodburning fireplace. Resources Real Estate
Advertisement

The property has been featured in number of movies, according to the listing, and has appeared in many ads including those for Brooks Brothers, Victoria’s Secret, and fashion magazines such as Vogue, the listing notes.

“I am so excited to bring such a unique piece of history to the market,” listing agent Katherine Raftery at Resources Real Estate said in a statement. “This is truly a rare opportunity – the setting and architecture are something that must be seen to fully appreciate.”

“The property is ‘farm accessed’ and generates income from the sale of farm goods,” the listing adds.

The home is 10-minute drive to some prime beaches.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy