Logo

The Connecticut man who shot three Bristol cops after luring them with a phony 911 call was a beer-drinking, divorced dad of two whom stunned neighbors described as the “rowdy one” in his clan.

Cop-killer Nicholas Brutcher, 35, also liked guns — and is seen proudly displaying a handgun at a wedding in one Facebook post from 2016.

“Nick was the big, rowdy one,” a neighbor of his brother Nathaniel told The Post on Thursday.

“He was the big, funny one, a big teddy bear. He was huge. Big guy, but sweet as pie.

“The family must be traumatized,” she added.

Bristol cops were responding to a 911 call about a domestic dispute at Nicholas Brutcher’s home — a phony call to lure cops to the house, according to authorities — and he opened fire when they arrived, killing two and wounding one.

Nicholas was killed by police at the scene, while younger brother Nathaniel was wounded in the Wednesday night shootout and remains hospitalized, according to police.

It is unclear if Nathaniel also shot at officers or was a bystander or a victim.

According to NBC Connecticut, Nicholas had been kicked out of a bar, then went home and got into an altercation with his brother.


  Nicholas Brutcher holds a gun in a photo posted to his Facebook. Facebook / Nicholas Brutcher Nicholas Brutcher holds a gun in a photo posted to his Facebook. Facebook / Nicholas Brutcher

He is said to have called 911 at 10:29 p.m. and waited with an AR-15-style gun for officers to arrive, according to the station.

Bristol police have yet to determine a motive for the shooting, and have released few additional details about the circumstances — calling it a “complex investigation.”

Police Sgt. Dustin Demonte, 35, and Officer Alex Hamzy, 34, were killed at the scene, while a third cop, Officer Alec Iurato, 26, was wounded and underwent surgery Thursday.

Speaking about the brothers’ reputation, the neighbor added: “Nobody’s gonna like those boys, no matter what you say about them. I’m really mad at them.”

1 of 5
Officer Alec Iurato of the Bristol Police Department.
Officer Alec Iurato of the Bristol Police Department.Connecticut State Police
Officer Alex Hamzy
Officer Alex HamzyConnecticut State Police
Advertisement
Sgt. Dustin Demonte
Sgt. Dustin DemonteConnecticut State Police
Advertisement

However, the same neighbor also described how Nathaniel called her “Grandma,” and recently dropped off a jar of homemade pickles — one of 53 jars he boasted he made.

Nicholas and Nathaniel also have two brothers and an adopted sister, she added.

A different neighbor described Nathaniel as “a skater punk” and “a man-child” who lives in a trash-strewn trailer with beer cans piled up on the unkempt property.

He also believed he was into drugs, adding: “Nate is high as a kite every time I see him. But cocaine doesn’t drive you to call cops and shoot them.”

He said Nicholas would visit his brother on occasion and was “always drinking.”


  Nicholas Brutcher was a divorced father of two.
 Nicholas Brutcher was a divorced father of two.

  Nicholas and Nate Brutcher hold guns at a wedding. Facebook Nicholas and Nate Brutcher hold guns at a wedding. Facebook

“I don’t know much about [Nicholas], except he drinks a lot,” he said. “The dude’s always drinking. He’d be around, checking on his brother.

“Their mother must be a wreck right now,” he added. “She’s also crazier than a f–king bag of chips.

“Their dad’s really got his s–t together. He’s got a really good heart. He’s been taking care of their mother and those boys for years. That dude’s a strong man.

“After this, I don’t know,” he said.

1 of 5
Facebook photos of Nathan Brutcher
Nathaniel Brutcher holds a gun.Facebook / nate.brutcher
Facebook photos of Nathan Brutcher
Nathaniel Brutcher was injured at the scene. Facebook / nate.brutcher
Advertisement
Facebook photos of Nathan Brutcher
Nathaniel Brutcher was also at the incident but his involvement is unclear.Facebook / nate.brutcher
Advertisement

Hamzy, a Bristol native and 2006 graduate of Bristol Eastern High School, leaves behind his wife, Katie, his parents and two sisters, authorities said.

Delmonte is survived by his pregnant wife, Laura, and daughters Phoebe and Porter.

In a separate report, the Connecticut Post reported Thursday that Iurato had received a commendation last year for thwarting a suicide attempt.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy