Logo

Lindsay Shiver, the Georgia housewife accused of orchestrating a hit against her estranged husband, denied the allegations after appearing in court in the Bahamas Tuesday. 

Shiver, who allegedly plotted to kill Robert Shiver with the aid of her Bahamian boyfriend Terrance Adrien Bethel and accused hitman Faron Newbold, exited the courthouse in Nassau and simply mouthed “no” and shook her head when reporters asked her about the allegations. 

The mother-of-three appeared beleaguered and worn out, stepping out of a prisoner’s bus arriving from the island’s notorious Fox Hill Prison, where she has been held for the past 18 days.

Shiver, 36, sported a fitted gray T-shirt, flip-flops, ripped jeans, pink nail polish, and dirty blonde hair styled in a bun.

After a whole day in court discussing the conditions of her $100,000 bail, a judge declined her release Tuesday and pushed the decision for Wednesday, when she is due to return along with her alleged co-conspirators.  

She stepped back onto the bus with a dazed look and attempted to shield her face with a manila envelope. 

If released Wednesday, she will have to remain on the island after she was ordered to hand over her travel documents and agree to wear a GPS tracker as part of her bail agreement.


  Lindsay Shiver, who is accused of plotting to kill her estranged husband, appeared at a Nassau courthouse in the Bahamas on Tuesday morning. Selim Algar / NY Post Lindsay Shiver, who is accused of plotting to kill her estranged husband, appeared at a Nassau courthouse in the Bahamas on Tuesday morning. Selim Algar / NY Post

  Police say they uncovered a plot Lindsay orchestrated with her Bahamian boyfriend and a hitman to kill Robert Shiver, the father of her three children. Instagram/Lindsay Shiver Police say they uncovered a plot Lindsay orchestrated with her Bahamian boyfriend and a hitman to kill Robert Shiver, the father of her three children. Instagram/Lindsay Shiver

Shiver is also barred from contacting estranged husband Robert, 38, an executive vice president of Senior Life Insurance Company and a former Auburn football player.

It was the first-time Shiver has been seen since she and her alleged accomplices were spotted on video being walked through an airport on the island of Great Abaco by police, who flew them to Nassau for processing following their arrest on July 21.

Bethel, 28, and Newbold, 29, were released from prison days earlier after each posting their $20,000 bond. Both men are back in Abaco.

The trio claimed there was never a serious assassination plot to kill Robert, 38, who had filed for divorce against Shiver in April citing her infidelity as a reason.


  Lindsay made her first appearance after being locked up at the notorious Fox Hill Prison for 18 days.
 Lindsay made her first appearance after being locked up at the notorious Fox Hill Prison for 18 days.

  Terrance Adrien Bethel said he was in love with Lindsay and that the alleged murder plot was something they hatched out of frustration and wasn’t meant to be taken seriously. Daniel William McKnight for NY Post Terrance Adrien Bethel said he was in love with Lindsay and that the alleged murder plot was something they hatched out of frustration and wasn’t meant to be taken seriously. Daniel William McKnight for NY Post

  Faron Newbold was allegedly in talks with the couple to kill Robert Shiver. Faron Newbold/Facebook Faron Newbold was allegedly in talks with the couple to kill Robert Shiver. Faron Newbold/Facebook

Bethel broke his silence Monday, claiming that the allegations stemming from what police uncovered on his phone while investigating a separate crime were false.

“Everybody says things out of frustration,” Bethel told the Daily Mail about incriminating messages, claiming he and Shiver were just venting over her marriage woes.

Included in the phone was a message allegedly sent to Newbold containing a picture of Robert with “kill him” written on it.


  Lindsay is expected to be freed from prison after posting a $100,000 bond. Lindsay Shiver/Instagram Lindsay is expected to be freed from prison after posting a $100,000 bond. Lindsay Shiver/Instagram

Prior to her arrest, Shiver was set to testify before a Georgia court in her divorce proceedings, where she was expected to discuss allegations of domestic abuse against Robert.

While Shiver remains in the Bahamas, Robert is currently living in the couple’s $2.5 million mansion in Thomasville, Georgia, with their three boys.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy