Luigi Mangione wants a laptop in jail so he can help prepare his defense for his trial for the broad daylight execution of the UnitedHealthcare CEO, his lawyers said.
But, prosecutors are objecting — citing threats that have already been made to witnesses in the extremely high profile case.
Mangione, 26, has asked for access to a restricted laptop, solely for viewing case evidence like videos, photos and 15,000 pages of records, according to court papers filed in his criminal Manhattan Supreme Court case for the murder of healthcare head Brian Thompson.
Luigi Mangione is asking for a laptop in jail as he awaits trial in the killing of UnitedHealthcare’s CEO. Steven Hirsch for NY Post“Without a discovery laptop, Mr. Mangione cannot meaningfully assist in his own defense,” Mangione’s lawyer Karen Agnifilo wrote in court papers made public Monday.
Mangione would not have access to the internet and would not be able to use the laptop for games or entertainment while he’s locked up at Brooklyn’s beleaguered Metropolitan Detention Center, his lawyer said.
It is not uncommon for other inmates to be allowed to have access to restricted laptops as Mangione is requesting.
But, defense lawyers complain that prosecutors in Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s Office are “inexplicably” opposing Mangione’s request for the computer.
Mangione is accused of gunning down Brian Thompson (pictured) in December outside a Manhattan hotel. UnitedHealth Group
Surveillance footage outside the midtown Hilton Hotel shows the moment Thompson was gunned down. Obtained by NY PostStay up to date on Luigi Mangione, charged with murdering UnitedHealthcare CEO
- UnitedHealth concealed how backlash from CEO Brian Thompson’s killing was hurting profit: shareholder lawsuit
- Luigi Mangione gets killer 27th birthday present as defense fund tops $1M: ‘The man, the myth, the legend.’
- Diehard Luigi Mangione fans rally outside courthouse as he fights for his life in death penalty case
- Calif. ballot measure named after Luigi Mangione would make it illegal to ‘delay, deny’ healthcare coverage: ‘Crazy’
- Luigi Mangione releases first public statement since alleged murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO
They told his legal team by email: “Given the sensitive nature of many of the documents and the threats that several witnesses have already received, we do not plan on consenting to a personal laptop at this time.”
The DA’s office “has no basis to believe that Mr. Mangione has any connection to the alleged witness threats,” Agnifilo wrote, noting that prosuectors hadn’t even disclosed the names of witnesses to the defense yet.
“Mr. Mangione had no part in disseminating their names,” the defense lawyer insisted.
Mangione, an Ivy League computer science graduate from a Maryland real estate family, has pleaded not guilty to the New York state charges. Steven Hirsch for NY PostStill, Agnifilo said the defense will agree to only load the laptop with “non-sensitive and non-civilian-related” evidence — with the sensitive information only being viewed by Mangione in the presence of his lawyers.
If Mangione is not ultimately allowed to use a laptop, he won’t be able to review all the photos and videos in time for the current court schedule and the lawyers would have to print out 15,000 pages of records for him, Agnifilo’s filing said.
Agnifilo also accused the DA’s office of withholding critical evidence in the case that was due months ago — all while law enforcement has allegedly been leaked confidential information to the press.
He also faces a parallel federal case that carries the possibility of the death penalty. Robert MillerAll of this risks prejudicing potential jury members and could mean Mangione wouldn’t get a fair shake at trial, Agnifilo complained.
“Not only is there no connection to Mr. Mangione for any of said alleged threats, but all public statements about this case have come from law enforcement and the mayor of the City of New York, who have been leaking sensitive information and appearing in interviews on television, newspapers, and magazines, all prejudicing Mr. Mangione’s right ot a fair trial,” the filing alleges.
Mangione is charged in the New York state case with first-degree murder as an act of terrorism for allegedly gunning down Thompson on Dec. 4 outside of a Midtown Manhattan hotel.
Mangione hasn’t entered a plea to the federal charges or to state-level gun possession and other charges in Pennsylvania, where he was arrested days after Thompson’s death. Paul Martinka
Through his lawyers, Mangione has released a statement thanking his many supporters. Robert MillerHe’s also charged in a federal case with stalking and murder and use of a silencer in a crime of violence. In a third state case in Pennsylvania, Mangione is fighting gun and false identification charges following a five-day manhunt to track him down after the shooting. He’s pleaded not guilty to all of the allegations.
Mangione received a master’s degree in computer science at the prestigious University of Pennsylvania in 2020.
He has drawn a cult-following of supporters as many have become disenchanted with percieved corporate greed and the American healthcare system. A legal defense fund for Mangione has already raised nearly $760,000.
The DA’s declined to comment saying they would respond in court papers.






