Logo

A Massachusetts mom wants her murder trial split into two parts so a jury can separately decide if she was insane and suffering from postpartum psychosis when she allegedly murdered her three kids.

Lindsay Clancy wants one trial for a jury to determine if she is responsible for fatally strangling kids Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and 8-month-old Callan with an exercise band at their Duxbury, Mass. home on January 2023.

And she wants a second, separate phase of trial for jurors to decide if she was suffering from a “mental disease or defect” when she allegedly slayed her children, according to papers filed by her lawyer, Kevin Reddington Thursday.


  Lindsay Clancy wants a separate trial determine if she was insane at the time she allegedly murdered her three kids. Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images Lindsay Clancy wants a separate trial determine if she was insane at the time she allegedly murdered her three kids. Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

The second phase of trial would presumably be moot if she was acquitted at the first phase.

Clancy made a rare appearance in Plymouth court Friday afternoon when previously she usually appeared by video for hearings.

She listened attentively as the judge and the lawyers set a next court date for March 2 for oral arguments on various issues, including her bid for a split trial, and discussed her upcoming April 10 mental evaluation to be conducted by an expert chosen by prosecutors. 

Judge William F. Sullivan said he wanted the exam to happen soon, adding: “That test is going forward on that date no matter what.” 

Sullivan also asked Clancy and her lawyer if they wanted her to be brought back to court for future hearings.


  Clancy allegedly strangled her kids with an elastic workout band in 2023. Facebook / Lindsay Marie Clancy Clancy allegedly strangled her kids with an elastic workout band in 2023. Facebook / Lindsay Marie Clancy

Defense attorney Kevin Reddington leaned over and spoke with Clancy before telling the judge, “I’d like to have her here.”

When the hearing wrapped, a court officer pushed Clancy, a paraplegic bound to a wheelchair,  out of the courtroom.

She became paralyzed when she cut her neck and jumped from a window after slaying her children.

Reddington had previously fought over logistics of getting Clancy to court during trial, which is currently scheduled for July.


  Clancy has claimed in a lawsuit that her doctors overmedicated her and failed to diagnose her with bipolar disorder with a postpartum onset. Facebook / Lindsay Marie Clancy Clancy has claimed in a lawsuit that her doctors overmedicated her and failed to diagnose her with bipolar disorder with a postpartum onset. Facebook / Lindsay Marie Clancy

Reddington also filed papers requesting that Clancy’s upcoming mental evaluation by prosecutors’ expert be videotaped so the defense attorney can review it in lieu of being present for the exam.

Sullivan said they would discuss that request further at the next hearing.

Prosecutors last month asked that they be able to evaluate Clancy with their own expert after her lawyers announced her main defense would be that she was innocent of the crimes because she was having a mental break when she carried them out.

The mom has claimed in a lawsuit suit that a revolving door of doctors missed that she was suffering from bipolar disorder while loading her up with myriad drugs from October to December of 2022, like Zoloft, trazodone, Prozac, Ambien, Remeron, Klonopin, Seroquel, Ativan, Valium, and Lamictal.

And Clancy began to wonder if she was a “psychopath,” her suit claimed.

She was overtaken by a “force” with the voice of a man she began hearing since she started taking Seroquel, the day she killed her kids.

It wasn’t until over a year after her arrest that she was diagnosed with bipolar disorder — a condition that antidepressants usually make worse, the suit said.

Her husband, Patrick Clancy, filed a separate lawsuit against her doctors claiming she was “overmedicated” at the time of the killings.

At a hearing in December, where Clancy appeared by video, her lawyer warned the judge of the logistical nightmare of getting her to court for trial everyday, as he requested an ambulance for her transportation.

Reddington also warned that she may try to kill herself during the course of trial.

Clancy has been on suicide watch at Tewksbury State Hospital since her arrest.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy