Logo

A school of about “50 sand sharks” was spotted off a Long Island beach Tuesday morning, officials said — just hours after a girl was bitten at the same beach and nearby a boy suffered injuries in the first confirmed shark attack of the season.

But state parks officials later walked back the claim, saying the would-be man-eaters were actually just a school of large harmless fish known as black drum.

The fish were seen schooling about 200 yards off Robert Moses Beach around 8 a.m. before beaches opened for the busy Fourth of July holiday as staff conducted a precautionary check of the waters.

“There were about 50 sand sharks that we saw,” Long Island Parks Regional Director George Gorman told The Post — before his office issued a clarification later in the week.

“Obviously, we did not open for swimming at 8 o’clock when lifeguards came on duty.”

Gorman said staff monitored the fish with surveillance drones for about an hour and a half before they determined the beaches were safe and opened for the day around 9:30 a.m.


  Tiger sharks, also known as sand sharks, have a distinct striped pattern.
 Tiger sharks, also known as sand sharks, have a distinct striped pattern.

  Black drum, which typically grow no bigger than 30 pounds, have ray fins and a striped pattern. Smithsonian Environmental Research Center. Black drum, which typically grow no bigger than 30 pounds, have ray fins and a striped pattern. Smithsonian Environmental Research Center.

  Robert Moses Beach was closed briefly to swimmers on the Fourth of July. WABC Robert Moses Beach was closed briefly to swimmers on the Fourth of July. WABC

“Sand sharks are very common off of Long Island,” Gorman said, noting that the large school was not something out of the ordinary, but that “individuals are more common.”

The would-be shark sightings came after a 15-year-old girl swimming off Robert Moses Beach around 1:45 p.m. Monday said something bit her leg.

She suffered small puncture wounds, but it remains unconfirmed whether she was munched on by a shark or another marine animal.

Gorman said he didn’t want to speculate on what might’ve bitten the girl as there were no witnesses.

Hours later, and just three miles west on Fire Island, a 15-year-old boy was surfing at Kismet Beach when a shark took a bite at his feet and left him with puncture wounds in his ankle and toes.


  The beach was closed from 8 a.m. to 9:30 a.m. NYS Parks The beach was closed from 8 a.m. to 9:30 a.m. NYS Parks

  Teens reported being bitten at a different beach on Monday. Getty Images/iStockphoto Teens reported being bitten at a different beach on Monday. Getty Images/iStockphoto

He swam to shore and a bystander helped him as they waited for officers from the county Marine Bureau to arrive.

The boy was taken to Good Samaritan University Hospital in West Islip with his ankle and toes intact, Suffolk County police said.

Authorities confirmed the boy was attacked by a shark of some kind.

Despite their frightening ragged-toothed appearance, sand sharks are generally docile creatures.

On the rare occasion they do bite humans, it is usually because hands or feet were mistaken for the bunker or other baitfish they feed on. When attacks do occur on Long Island, it is not uncommon for them to be from sand sharks.

The confirmed Fire Island bite was the first of the 2023 summer season on Long Island following eight reported attacks last year — an unusually high number that resulted in Gov. Kathy Hochul bolstering surveillance capabilities.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy