Logo
US NewsUS News

Potential Jet Aaron Rodgers hasn’t even hit an NYC tarmac yet, and he’s already landed an impossible-to-get reservation at the oracle of orecchiette, Rao’s.

The gridiron great is currently on standby while Gang Green and the Green Bay Packers work out a trade that will bring the 39-year-old NFL superstar to the Big Apple.

But New Yorkers are already rolling out the welcome mat.

“As long as you ain’t a vegetarian, you come to New York and we are going to break your cherry,” said celebrity Private Investigator Bo Dietl.

He told The Post he’ll make the quarterback an offer he can’t refuse — dinner at the famously exclusive East Harlem eatery, where Dietl’s had Table No. 1 on Thursday nights since 1977.

If he accepts, Rodgers will be following in the footsteps of Phil Simms, Joe Montana, Boomer Esiason, and Peyton Manning, who celebrated his second Super Bowl title at Rao’s with brother Eli in February 2016.


  “As long as you ain’t a vegetarian, you come to New York and we are going to break your cherry,” said Dietl. Lars Niki “As long as you ain’t a vegetarian, you come to New York and we are going to break your cherry,” said Dietl. Lars Niki

  Rao’s off-the-charts food choices include meatballs Rodgers “can’t get “in Green Bay, Dietl promised. Andrew H. Walker Rao’s off-the-charts food choices include meatballs Rodgers “can’t get “in Green Bay, Dietl promised. Andrew H. Walker

When Rodgers isn’t being showered with baked clams and bolognese sauce, he likes a good steak, according to a midtown Manhattan scouting report.

In January 2014, the Green Bay signal caller supped at Benjamin Steakhouse on East 41st Street with friends after appearing on “Late Night with Jimmy Fallon,” Page Six reported.

“He’s been here four or five times. I’d love to see him more,” owner Benjamin Prelvukaj told The Post, adding, “He loves the ribeye” — and tips well.

In June 2014, Rodgers was spotted with then-girlfriend Olivia Munn at The Skylark cocktail bar in the Garment District after attending the Cinema Society party for the horror flick “Deliver Us From Evil.”

No cheesehead, Rodgers cleaned up nicely leaving the Carlyle Hotel with Munn for the 2015 Met Gala, whose theme was: “China: Through the Looking Glass.”


  Benjamin Steakhouse is also putting out the welcome mat for Rodgers, who has dined there on multiple occasions. BenJaminâs Steak House Benjamin Steakhouse is also putting out the welcome mat for Rodgers, who has dined there on multiple occasions. BenJaminâs Steak House

  Rodgers and actress Olivia Munn stayed at the Carlyle Hotel. Getty Images Rodgers and actress Olivia Munn stayed at the Carlyle Hotel. Getty Images

  Rodgers and Munn attended the 2015 Met Gala. GC Images Rodgers and Munn attended the 2015 Met Gala. GC Images

  Rodgers and Munn leave The Carlyle in 2015 to attend the Met Gala. Ilya S. Savenok Rodgers and Munn leave The Carlyle in 2015 to attend the Met Gala. Ilya S. Savenok

In August 2017, Rodgers, who had by then moved on from Munn, was spotted on a date with 24-year-old soccer player Marie Margolius at the Upper East Side celebrity haunt The East Pole.

“They arrived at around 10 p.m. and seemed to be on a date. He wore a baseball cap and asked for the quietest, most out-of-the-way table possible,” Page Six reported.

“His hat was tilted down. It definitely seemed like he wanted to be incognito,” an insider said.


  In August 2017, Rodgers went on an under-the-radar date with soccer player Marie Margolius at the Upper East Side celebrity haunt the East Pole. Helayne Seidman In August 2017, Rodgers went on an under-the-radar date with soccer player Marie Margolius at the Upper East Side celebrity haunt the East Pole. Helayne Seidman

  Peyton and Eli Manning celebrated at Rao’s in the days after Peyton’s Denver Broncos defeated the Carolina Panthers in Super Bowl 50. Getty Images Peyton and Eli Manning celebrated at Rao’s in the days after Peyton’s Denver Broncos defeated the Carolina Panthers in Super Bowl 50. Getty Images

The athletic duo sat close to each other in a quiet booth and feasted on cheeseburgers and monkfish, quaffing malbec and pinot noir.

East Pole co-owner Tom Martignetti, 43, said he would love to see Rodgers in Jets green.

“He’s a cool dude,” he said.

“He’s the kind of guy you’d want to have a drink with. Compared to Wisconsin, he’s going to have a ball in New York City.”


  Legendary quarterback Joe Montana is also a Rao’s fan. AP Legendary quarterback Joe Montana is also a Rao’s fan. AP

  Boomer Esiason and Phil Simms are among the superstar quarterbacks who have dined at Rao’s. Getty Images for Breitling Boomer Esiason and Phil Simms are among the superstar quarterbacks who have dined at Rao’s. Getty Images for Breitling

Dietl agreed: “You can’t get f–king Rao’s meatballs in Green Bay.”

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy