Logo

The retired FBI supervisor who led the federal probe into the Lufthansa heist told The Post on Thursday that he “had a feeling” the case might be too threadbare to convict accused mobster Vincent Asaro.

“My gut feeling was that they didn’t have enough evidence,” said Stephen Carbone, 74, who spent countless hours probing the infamous Dec. 11, 1978, ripoff.

“When I realized that the only witness was the cousin, I didn’t feel that would be enough to convict,” he said.

Carbone, who is long retired from the bureau, said he monitored the trial’s developments by reading daily newspaper accounts and spoke with federal officials before the trial started.

He insisted that he had “no inside knowledge” on whether Asaro was guilty of plotting the heist with Jimmy “The Gent” Burke, as the government charged.

Carbone recalled Asaro’s name emerging during the course of the lengthy and far-flung investigation but only as one of many mob soldiers who were active back then.

“He was a soldier,” Carbone said of Asaro. “He was significant as any other soldier in the group [the Bonanno crime family]. We did not target him.”

The name of Gaspare Valenti — Asaro’s cousin who wore a wire for years and whose cooperation with authorities led to Asaro’s arrest in January 2014 — did not surface in the immediate aftermath of the Lufthansa heist, Carbone noted.

Carbone said that while he did not attend the trial himself, he spoke to a number of people who did — he declined to say whether they were law enforcement officials — and they too “didn’t feel there was enough evidence” to convict Asaro.

“Here’s the deal: From what I remember, I know there is a general policy that when you go to trial [in federal court], you feel confident 90 percent of the time,” he said.

“I’m sure they put a lot of work into it and feel very disappointed.”

1 of 18
The Lufthansa Heist makes the front page on Dec. 11, 1978.
The Lufthansa heist makes the front page on Dec. 11, 1978.New York Post
A July 18, 1984 graphic detailing the Lufthansa Heist
A graphic detailing the Lufthansa heistNew York Post
Advertisement
James "Jimmy the Gent" Burke in his April 12, 1979 mugshot, left, and as portrayed by Robert De Niro
James "Jimmy the Gent" Burke in his April 12, 1979, mugshot (left), and as portrayed by Robert De Niro in "Goodfellas."FBI / Warner Bros.
James "Jimmy the Gent" Burke is led handcuffed from a law enforcement vehicle in April 1979.
James "Jimmy the Gent" Burke is led handcuffed from a law enforcement vehicle in April 1979.AP
Henry Hill at his old haunts in Queens and as portrayed by Ray Liotta
Henry Hill at his old haunts in Queens and as portrayed by Ray LiottaPacific Coast News / Warner Bros.
Advertisement
Henry Hill poses for his mugshot in North Platte, Neb., on March 21, 2005.
Henry Hill poses for his mugshot in North Platte, Neb., on March 21, 2005.Pacific Coast News
Tommy DeSimone in January 1979 and as Tommy DeVito, portrayed by Joe Pesci
Tommy DeSimone in January 1979 and as Tommy DeVito, portrayed by Joe PesciFBI / Warner Bros.
Parnell "Stacks" Edwards in a Nov. 26, 1974 mugshot and as portrayed by Samuel L. Jackson
Parnell "Stacks" Edwards in a Nov. 26, 1974, mugshot and as portrayed by Samuel L. JacksonFBI / Warner Bros.
Advertisement
Martin Krugman as "Morrie Kessler," portrayed by Chuck LowFBI / Warner Bros.
Paul Vario in his October 1972 mugshot and as portrayed by Paul Sorvino
Paul Vario in his October 1972 mugshot and as portrayed by Paul SorvinoFBI / Warner Bros.
Police cordon off an area around a stolen black van in Brooklyn on Dec. 13, 1978.
Police cordon off an area around a stolen black van in Brooklyn on Dec. 13, 1978.AP
Advertisement
The original Lufthansa Heist story plasters the Dec. 11, 1978 paper.
The original Lufthansa heist story plasters the Dec. 11, 1978, paper.New York Post
Vincent Asaro's arrest makes the Friday, Jan. 24, 2014 New York Post cover.
Vincent Asaro's arrest makes the Friday, Jan. 24, 2014, New York Post cover.New York Post
Advertisement

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy