Logo

A former Metropolitan Detention Center corrections officer accused of raping a female inmate is getting a new trial because prosecutors failed to turn over evidence that could potentially have exonerated him, according to court papers.

A jury convicted ex-guard Carlos Martinez in January 2018 of aggravated sexual abuse, sexual abuse of a ward, and other charges for the repeated rape of a woman identified in court as “Maria.”

The ex-guard was arrested alongside two other officers who were accused of sexually assaulting female inmates at the MDC — including Eugenio Perez, who was identified due to his distinctive, hooked-shaped penis. Perez was convicted at trial and is awaiting sentencing.

But now Brooklyn federal Judge Edward Korman has ordered a new trial for Martinez, based on the statements of another inmate identified as “Jane Doe #4” that he says differ markedly from the accuser’s trial testimony and recast “the key factual issue at trial: whether the relationship between Maria and Martinez was consensual.”

“Jane Doe’s testimony may not inexorably lead to an acquittal in this case,” Korman writes in his July 2 decision. “But even if the suppressed evidence does not mandate acquittal, it raises a reasonable probability of a different outcome.”

Doe told investigators that Maria avoided interactions with prison staff that could reveal her relationship with 49-year-old Martinez, and would create scenarios in which she could be alone with him, the documents say.

While Martinez’s conviction stands on charges of sexual abuse of a ward — given that Maria was an inmate and therefore incapable of consent — he will be retried on the aggravated sexual abuse and sexual abuse charges.

The US Attorney’s Office declined to comment.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy