Daniel Penny, the former Marine charged with fatally choking homeless subway busker Jordan Neely on a crowded Manhattan train car, stood and waved Monday to the first batch of jurors that could decide his fate — as protestors jeered at him on his way into court.
“Murderer! Murderer!” one man shouted into a bullhorn as Penny, 25, walked into Manhattan Supreme Court for the first day of jury selection at his trial, where he’s charged with manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide.
About 50 demonstrators — including some holding signs that read “Justice for Jordan Neely: End Racist Vigilantism Now!” — rallied outside the Centre Street courthouse before Penny arrived.
Daniel Penny arrives to Manhattan criminal court in New York, Monday, Oct. 21, 2024. AP
Daniel Penny faces up to 19 years in prison if convicted in the lightning-rod case. Steven HirschOnce inside, Penny, wearing a blue suit and maroon tie, stood at the defense table, turned and waved to the first pool of prospective jurors sworn in Monday morning after Justice Maxwell Wiley asked him to introduce himself.
“Good morning,” he said softly.
When Wiley asked the first pool of 86 potential jurors who among them had heard of the lightning-rod case, nearly all of the hands shot up.
“Almost everybody. Not a surprise,” the judge said.
“Even if you have formed an opinion about it, that does not disqualify you from serving on this case,” he added. “If you have formed an opinion on this case, you have to be prepared to change it.”
Wiley then asked if they felt they had the time to serve in a trial expected to last up to six weeks, and by the midday lunch break, 58 prospective panelists had been excused.
Twenty-eight others were sent home for the day but told to return Friday morning for what’s expected to be the start of the second stage of the process: voir dire, or juror questioning.
In the afternoon session, 17 more prospective jurors were told to return Friday, while 35 more were excused. That means that by the end of the day Monday, 45 prospective jurors had made it past the first phase of screening, expected to resume on Tuesday morning.
People protesting against Penny outside of Manhattan Criminal Court during jury selection on Oct. 21, 2024. Gregory P. Mango
Shellyne Rodriguez, the college professor who threatened a Post reporter with a machete last year, at the protest calling for Penny to be convicted. Gregory P. Mango
A demonstrator with a sign calling for Penny to be convicted. Gregory P. Mango
Supporters of Penny gathered outside of Manhattan Criminal Court. SARAH YENESEL/EPA-EFE/ShutterstockProspective jurors are eventually expected to be grilled about their own experiences riding city subways — before 12 Manhattanites are ultimately chosen to decide whether to convict Penny of crimes that together carry a max sentence of 19 years.
The May 1, 2023 tragedy sparked a firestorm over whether Penny’s actions were justified when he confronted 30-year-old Neely — who some witnesses say had been ranting in an “insanely threatening” way — on a northbound F train as it neared the Broadway-Lafayette platform just after 2 p.m.
Penny was cut loose by police on the night of Neely’s death, but was arrested two weeks later after cellphone video of the fatal chokehold surfaced online and drew outrage.
Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s office has accused Penny of “recklessly” causing Neely’s death by choking him for more than six minutes — well past the point where Neely had stopped “purposeful movement.”
Penny kept Neely in a chokehold for more than six minutes, the DA’s office says. Juan VazquezThe chokehold also continued after the subway car’s doors had opened, allowing terrified passengers to flee the scene, and after two more men began restraining Neely as well, prosecutors say.
Penny’s lawyers have argued that he is being “persecuted” for what they say was him protecting his fellow straphangers from a raving Neely, who had yelled at some point, “someone is going to die today!”
But Neely was unarmed at the time — carrying just a muffin in his pocket, video of the scene shows — and other witnesses reported not feeling like he truly planned to hurt anyone.
“For me, it was like another day typically in New York,” one bystander told the grand jury.
Penny has pleaded not guilty.
A sketch of Daniel Penny in Manhattan Criminal Court i for jury selection on Oct. 21, 2024. REUTERS/Jane Rosenberg
Penny waving to potential jurors in court. sketch. REUTERS/Jane Rosenberg
Penny has been charged with manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide. REUTERS/Jane RosenbergWitnesses are set to include the detectives who interrogated Penny on the night of Neely’s death, and bystanders who were on the subway at the time.
It’s not yet clear whether Penny, who is out on $100,000 bail, will testify in his own defense.
Penny’s lead attorney, Thomas Kenniff, ran against Manhattan DA Bragg as a Republican in the November 2021 election. Bragg, a Democrat, won with 83% of the vote.
The protestors outside court Monday included Neely’s uncle, Christopher Neely, and Shellyne Rodriguez, who was fired from her job as an adjunct professor at Hunter College and the School of Visual Arts after she was caught on video threatening a Post reporter with a machete as he questioned her in May 2023.






