Logo

Two Brooklyn women who went wild on cops as they busted one of their boyfriends — a wanted ATM thief — have gotten a hefty payday for their bad attitudes, The Post has learned.

Deborah Russo and her daughter, Sonni Sottile, scored a $25,000 settlement from the city thanks to a lawsuit they filed accusing cops of handling them too roughly as they flew into a rage during the 2013 arrest of Sottile’s beau, Nicholas Giampaolo.

Giampaolo, then 22, had been cowering in the women’s home in Mill Basin as cops were looking to arrest him for allegedly breaking into an ATM in Gravesend.

All hell broke loose after officers pulled him out of the house in handcuffs. Russo and Sottile hysterically objected to the bust and scuffled with police officers.

1 of 21
Sonni Sottile rushes outside in her pink pajama shorts and slippers as her boyfriend is arrested.Paul Martinka
The 18-year-old battles police.Paul Martinka
Advertisement
A simple arrest quickly escalates.Paul Martinka
Officers restrain Sonni Sottile.Paul Martinka
Officers subdue Sonni Sottile, 18, as her boyfriend is taken into custody.Paul Martinka
Advertisement
The scene unfolded at about 10 a.m. Tuesday.Paul Martinka
Nicholas Giampaolo, 22, under arrest.Paul Martinka
Deborah Russo, 48, in handcuffs.Paul Martinka
Advertisement
Sonni Sottile, 18, cries out.Paul Martinka
Sottile and Russo face obstruction, resisting arrest and disorderly conduct charges.Paul Martinka
Deborah Russo on the ground.Paul Martinka
Advertisement
The sloppy smackdown happened outside an apartment building in Mill Basin, Brooklyn.Paul Martinka
Sonni Sottile, 18, screams at an officer as her mother, Deborah Russo, is restrained.Paul Martinka
Mother and daughter react after Sonni Sottile's boyfriend, Nicholas Giampaolo, was arrested on grand larceny charges.Paul Martinka
Advertisement
Sonni Sottile and her mom, Deborah Russo handcuffed.Paul Martinka
Advertisement

Both women were taken to the ground by officers, handcuffed and arrested for disorderly conduct.

Cops said at the time that the mother and daughter physically interfered with the arrest and were justifiably charged.

Nicholas Giampaolo being taken into custody.Paul MartinkaNicholas Giampaolo being taken into custody.Paul Martinka

They also accused Sottile of swinging at them after they handcuffed Giampaolo.

Their cases were adjourned in contemplation of dismissal a few months later, and Russo and Sottile filed suit against the city and the officers.

Their case contended that the officers used force on them without cause and needlessly roughed them up. Their attorney did not respond to a request for comment.

The city ultimately decided to settle the case for $25,000.

“The settlement was in the best interest of the city,” said a spokesman for the city Law Department.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy