Logo

Nine Democratic candidates for NYC mayor, including the two frontrunners — ex-New York governor Andrew Cuomo and socialist state Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani — faced off Wednesday in the first debate of the 2025 primary election.

A clear “winner” did emerge.

Keep reading for all the key moments from the Dems’ sparring session.

What to know about the first NYC mayoral debate

And the winner is...everyone?

By Hannah Fierick

Moments after the debate, campaigns started flooding social media and their campaign email lists, claiming victory. It appears that almost every candidate believes that they came out on top.

"Zellnor Myrie delivers outstanding debate performance," read the subject of an email by Myrie's campaign.

Democratic mayoral candidates Andrew Cuomo, left, shakes hands with Zohran Mamdani, center, as Whitney Tilson reacts after participating in a Democratic mayoral primary debate, Wednesday, June 4, 2025, in New York. AP

"Mamdani Ready to serve, Cuomo ready for bed," said the release from Mamdani's camp.

"Cuomo Dominates First Mayoral Debate, Proves He's Only Candidate with Experience to Tackle Crises Facing City," read an email blast from team Cuomo.


"Scott is the 'Grown-Up' Candidate New Yorkers Are Looking For. Tonight Proved It," was Stringer's message.

Attorney General Tish James who endorsed Adrienne Adams said also said she "Won the debate hands down," in a post on X.

The next Mayor of New York City @AdrienneEAdams won the debate hands down.

She was poised and prepared to show us the future of the greatest city in the world.

— Tish James (@TishJames) June 5, 2025

The people have spoken: Best social media reactions to tonight's debate

By Zach Alexander

Missed opportunity for Zohran there. Cuomo said, "He doesn't know New York City", and Zohran should have smacked his ass back with the "bacon cheese and egg on an english muffin" comment.

— pyramus.eth (@pyramuscrypto) June 4, 2025

Did Andrew Cuomo just say that “taxes” is a four letter word?#BidenMoment

— Thomas the Political NinjaTrekkie (@PolNinjaTrekkie) June 5, 2025

Michael Blake been clocking Cuomo’s tea ALL NIGHT #nycmayoraldebate

— Dunni 💖 (@dunnibjones) June 4, 2025

Zohran Mamdani & Michael Blake crushed Cuomo in the NYC Democratic Mayoral Debate tonight pic.twitter.com/4Z8JQmKLJ2

— Antifascist Iowan (@EatMusk) June 5, 2025

How I think I'd rank NYC ballot
1. Zohran Mamdani
2. Adrienne Adams
3. Brad Lander
4. Michael Blake
5. Jessica Ramos

— Debbie Dingell Stan🇺🇦🇵🇸🇬🇪 (@AustinHoney30) June 5, 2025

If Cuomo can’t hold his own on this debate stage, how will he hold his own against Donald Trump?

— Chi Ossé (@OsseChi) June 5, 2025

That's a wrap! Debate report card: 'Cuomo hasn’t lost a step since leaving Albany'

By Carl Campanile

The debate has now wrapped, and according to GOP campaign strategist Bill O'Reilly, frontrunner Andrew Cuomo was at the center of the heated session.

"Overall: It was Andrew Cuomo vs. the Lilliputians, and the Lilliputians fell short," O'Reilly told The Post after the debate, which last just over two hours.

Democratic mayoral candidate Andrew Cuomo speaks during a Democratic mayoral primary debate, Wednesday, June 4, 2025, in New York. AP

"Someone needed to trip up the former governor to slow his momentum, but it was clear from the jump that wouldn't happen. Cuomo hasn’t lost a step since leaving Albany, and the field lacked the skill to crack him.

The most talked-about person, unsurprisingly, was President Trump."

Candidates call out Trump's attack on Columbia University, but acknowledge rise in Jewish hate in NYC

By David Propper

Candidates sharply criticized the Trump administration for stating Columbia University should lose its accreditation over its “indifference” to the harassment on Jewish students.

Democratic mayoral candidate Andrew Cuomo, center, speaks during a Democratic mayoral primary debate, Wednesday, June 4, 2025, in New York. AP
President Donald Trump gestures after speaking during a summer soiree on the South Lawn of the White House, Wednesday, June 4, 2025, in Washington. AP

“[Department of Education Sec. Linda] McMahon is not an educator, and Trump has no interest in funding our education,” Jessica Ramos said. “He is trying to make our education less accessible to students.”

Zohran Mamdani called it a “gross overreach” while Michael Blake called the “overreach unacceptable.”

Still, candidates mostly acknowledged that antisemitism has spiked in the Big Apple since the Oct. 7, 2023 attack on Israel and subsequent conflict in Gaza.

Columbia University students staged a pray-in in protest of Khalil's arrest and the second student's arrest on March 14, 2025 in New York City. Robert Miller

“This is a frightening time for Jews,” Brad Lander said while Zellnor Myrie said elected leaders need to work to root out Jewish hate.  

Andrew Cuomo jumps in after Mamdani refuses to say Israel has a right to exist as a 'Jewish state'

By David Propper

Andrew Cuomo jumped in when Zohran Mamdani again refused to say Israel has a right to exist as a “Jewish state.”

“I believe Israel has a right to exist,” Mamdani said to which the moderator replied, “As a Jewish state?”

Democratic mayoral candidate Andrew Cuomo pauses during a Democratic mayoral primary debate, Wednesday, June 4, 2025, in New York. via REUTERS
Democratic mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani speaks during a Democratic mayoral primary debate, Wednesday, June 4, 2025, in New York. AP

“As a state with equal rights,” he said.  

Cuomo, as well as Whitney Tilson, quickly cut in on the remark, with Cuomo pointing out Mamdani declined to say the nation should exist as a Jewish state.

“And his answer was no, he won’t visit Israel,” Cuomo said in reference to an earlier answer from Mamdani.

A Pro Palestinian protest to free Mahmoud Khalil. held this afternoon outside of Columbia University on Broadway at W 116st. Robert Miller

“Unlike you, I answer questions very directly,” Mamdani told Cuomo, “and I want to be very clear I believe every state should be a state of equal rights.”

How much is Cuomo's rent? He's given three different answers

By Craig McCarthy

Andrew Cuomo gave a different answer Wednesday when asked how much he pays in rent each month.

The ex-gov told the moderators he's paying $7,800 but when The Post reviewed his lease earlier this month, it listed $8,200 as the monthly fee and he paid just over $8,000 to start.

Andrew Cuomo arrives at his eastside apartment, NYC. Matthew McDermott

He gave a different answer to The New York Times earlier this week, saying " rent just went up to about $8,000."

Here's what the rest of the candidates said they pay for housing:

  • Lander: $3,300
  • Adams: "Our home is paid. I'm a homeowner."
  • Myrie: $1,300
  • Ramos: $2,500
  • Stringer: $6,400
  • Mamdani: $2,300
  • Blake: $1,800
  • Tilson: Owns but pays $5,000 in upkeep and taxes

READ MORE

Michael Blake only candidate who backs firing Knicks coach Tom Thibodeau

By Carl Campanile

The Rev. Michael Blake was the only candidate who supported the firing of Knick coach Tom Thibodeau, when asked, relatively early in the debate.

Candidate Michael Blake speaks during a Democratic mayoral primary debate, June 4, 2025, in New York, U.S. via REUTERS
New York Knicks head coach Tom Thibodeau yells from the sideline during the first half of Game 6 of the Eastern Conference finals of the NBA basketball playoffs against the Indiana Pacers in Indianapolis, Saturday, May 31, 2025 AP

"The goal is to win a championship!" he said.

Everyone else gave a thumbs down.

Candidates avoid offending powerful NYC teachers' union

By Carl Campanile

The leading Democratic candidates for mayor all want to be the teacher's union pet, critics said.

Front-runners Andrew Cuomo and Zohran Mamdani and others all took pains not to offend the United Federations of Teachers when asked that New York City spends $40 billion on public schools and what they would do to bolster student performance.

"They're making clear that they have no backbone and they will be pawns of the teacher union," GOP campaign strategist Bill O'Reilly said after hearing answers during Wednesday's Democratic primary debate for mayor.

Andrew Cuomo speaks during a Democratic mayoral primary debate as Zellnor Myrie and Whitney Tilson listen, June 4, 2025, in New York, U.S. via REUTERS

"They're going to continue to kill charter schools or private innovations. They're afraid to offend the union."

Financier Whitney Tilson was the only candidate who promoted popular charter schools as an option for students.

"There's bad management. There are few if any enough rewards for success and few if any consequences for failure," Tilson said.

"Charter schools are held accountable and not surprisingly they are overall the best public schools in the city delivering for kids.

A crowd made up of parents, students, teachers and school administrators gather by City Hall in Manhattan to demand the expansion of charter schools in NYC. Stephen Yang

Mamdani said too many students going to school hungry or are homeless and did not specify a plan.

Cuomo, who promoted charter schools as governor,  did not mention them.

He said he would look at the Department of Education's consultants and the curriculum.

Tillson was the only candidate who mentioned charter schools as an option for New York City students. NBC 4

"We need more paraprofessionals in the schools," added Cuomo, referring to teachers' aides who aid students with disabilities.

Boosting pay of paraprofessionals is a top priority of the UFT.

Other candidates talk of boosting 3-K and pre-k programs.

Mamdani calls out Cuomo's Chat GPT housing plan

By Hannah Fierick

When moderators asked about AI and if candidates would consider replacing city workers with the tech for tax breaks -- Mamdani pointed out that Cuomo has already - allegedly - replaced aides with one of the clever machines.

The ex-gov was recently accused of using AI model 'Chat GPT' to write the last pages of the housing plan -- which included bizarre typos and language. His staff, however, denied it -- and chalked it up to lazy editing.

Whitney Tilson championed AI when it was his turn to respond. "It will be a home run for the city!" he said.

Who's winning the debate? Ask yourself these questions

By Kaydi Pelletier

From body language expert Chris Ulrich:

"Candidates use these three elements to guide how they frame themselves in a debate — and voters should be asking themselves...

  • How does the candidate want me to feel about them?
  • What do they want me to notice about them?
  • How they have used their appearance, competence, confidence, presence to get my attention and tell me how they would lead NYC?"

No candidate says who they will rank second in Dem primary

By David Propper

No candidate answered who they would rank second when the Democratic primary happens later this month.

Zohran Mamdani would only say he would not rank Andrew Cuomo while Whitney Tilson said he would not rank Mamdani.

No candidate revealed who they would rank second in the mayoral primary. AP

Everyone else stage stayed mum on the question, with Adrienne Adams stating she would not be making news Wednesday night while Michael Blake said he would take Cuomo’s approach and not answer the question.

Cuomo spars with Mamdani over socialist's plan to finance $10B freebie proposals

By Matt Troutman

Ex-Gov. Andrew Cuomo lambasted socialist Zohran Mamdani's plans to finance $10 billion in freebies for New Yorkers as not rooted in "reality."

Cuomo argued Mamdani couldn't get a tax hike necessary for his plans through the state legislature.

Andrew Cuomo speaks during a Democratic mayoral primary debate as Zellnor Myrie and Whitney Tilson listen, June 4, 2025, in New York, U.S. via REUTERS

Mamdani then pounced back with a shot at Cuomo's past support for giving state subsidies to a solar panel plant bought by Elon Musk's Tesla.

"What the governor is speaking about is when we want to fight for working class people, it's considered unrealistic," Mamdani said. "But when he wants to give Elon Musk a $1 billion tax break, it's totally feasible."

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy