Logo

The Queens straphanger accused of fatally attacking a fellow rider for bumping into him on a subway platform was charged with manslaughter Tuesday and hauled off to court in handcuffs, police said. 

Carlos Garcia, 50, is accused of getting into a scuffle with a 48-year-old victim during Monday’s evening rush hour at the Jackson Heights-Roosevelt Avenue 74th Street subway station after the victim bumped into him on the platform, causing the suspect’s cell phone to fall on the tracks. 

When the victim refused to go down to the tracks to retrieve the fallen phone, Garcia got into a physical altercation with him as the pair screamed at each other in Spanish, witnesses and police sources said. 

Garcia, dressed in grey pants, a camouflage shirt and a blue sweater, made no comments when he was walked out of the 115th precinct and thrown into the back of a police car.


  Carlos Garcia, 50, is walked in handcuffs from the 115th precinct to a car to take him to court. Gabriella Bass Carlos Garcia, 50, is walked in handcuffs from the 115th precinct to a car to take him to court. Gabriella Bass

1 of 6
Carlos Garcia was charged with manslaughter for allegedly causing another man to fall onto the subway tracks at the Jackson Heights-Roosevelt Avenue 74th Street station in Queens on October 17, 2022.
Carlos Garcia was charged with manslaughter for allegedly causing another man to fall onto the subway tracks at the Jackson Heights-Roosevelt Avenue 74th Street station in Queens on October 17, 2022.Peter Gerber
Photo of subway crime scene
The 48-year-old was killed on Monday following a fight on the platform. Peter Gerber
Advertisement
Garcia and the victim had gotten into an argument after the victim bumped into Garcia and caused his phone to fall onto the tracks.
Garcia and the victim had gotten into an argument after the victim bumped into Garcia and caused his phone to fall onto the tracks.Peter Gerber
Police sources initially claimed Garcia pushed the victim in front of the train, but other sources have said the man fell during the scuffle.Peter Gerber
Advertisement

He’s expected to be arraigned on the charges at Queens Criminal Court later Tuesday.

Cop sources initially said Garcia then pushed the victim onto the tracks and into the path of an oncoming train, killing the man. But other police sources said Tuesday that the victim may have fallen onto the roadbed and into the train’s path amid the scuffle. 

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy