Logo
US NewsUS News

Who you callin’ a fat cat?

Threatened by proposed city cost cutting, 1,100 private attorneys who handle criminal cases involving indigent defendants insist they’re a bargain compared with the nonprofits they fear are trying to move in on their turf.

The nonprofit Legal Aid Society had three lawyers making more than $170,000 a year; New York County Defenders has three making more than $120,000; and the top two at Brooklyn Defender Services made $162,000 and $137,000, 2008 tax records show.

The private lawyers, who get $75 an hour for felony cases through the city-funded 18-B program, can make up to $200,000 but have to shell out for overhead expenses.

“We handle the most complicated, labor-intensive cases, which the not-for-profits are less equipped to handle,” said 18-B lawyer Bryan Konoski, who earns $190,000.

The nonprofits say it’s nonsense to compare 18-B earners to execs like Legal Aid’s Steven Banks, who oversees 1,450 staffers for about $200,000 a year.

Banks, “who typically works an 85-hour week and takes hardly any vacation, actually makes substantially less per hour,” said Legal Aid spokeswoman Pat Bath.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy