Federal Transit Administration boss Marc Molinaro has accused the MTA of ignoring its own safety rules following the 2023 death of a worker who was struck by a train and a second incident last year in which a worker was hit, but survived.
Molinaro, a former New York GOP congressman, demanded the agency submit a third safety and risk assessment, arguing the prior two reports were “flawed” and threatening to cut funding if the transit authority fails to “adequately” account for “escalating risk trends.”
Marc Molinaro warned that he won’t be asking for a fourth report if MTA fails to get the third one right. CQ-Roll Call, Inc via Getty Images“Secretary [Sean] Duffy has said time and again, safety is USDOT’s top priority, and we will not accept anything less than full accountability.”
Monilaro’s demand follows the November 2023 death of flagger Hilarion Joseph, 57, after he was fatally struck by an uptown D train near the 34th Street-Herald Square station.
The MTA held a safety refresher for work crew members in response to Joseph’s death, only to suffer a near-miss months later.
In June 2024, another flagger was hit by an F train at the Hoyt-Schermerhorn Street station in downtown Brooklyn, surviving despite severe head trauma.
Hilarion Joseph was killed by a train back in 2023. Transport Workers Union Local 100MTA’s Chief of Policy and External Relations John McCarthy blasted Molinaro’s threat, telling The Post in a statement that the FTA’s concerns were answered seven months ago, and alleging that the letter was motivated by the Trump administration’s opposition to congestion pricing.
“We are not surprised to receive this letter out of the blue now,” he said. “Clearly this was not urgent for Washington until it was decided it was time to fire off yet another letter and press release in what is a pattern of threatening letters and punitive actions by US DOT following New York’s successful implementation of the first in [the] nation Congestion Pricing program.”
“A Federal Judge has made it absolutely clear that punishing New York for maintaining Congestion Pricing is a violation of his injunction, which remains in effect,” McCarthy added. “We are reviewing this latest letter to determine any appropriate legal action.”
New York City Transit has had a sharp rise in near-misses over recent years. CitizenAn FTA audit has found that employees of New York City Transit (NYCT), a division of the MTA which operates the city’s subways and buses, suffered 38 potential near-misses during 2023 alone — up from 24 such incidents in 2022 and 23 in 2021.
Between 2013 and 2020, by contrast, NYCT experienced just 25 potential near-misses.
Under the Biden administration, the FTA began demanding that NYCT produce a “comprehensive risk assessment” of its Roadway Worker Protection (RWP) program.
NYCT had presented its first safety risk assessment to the FTA in October 2024, then submitted a second one in January after the first got rejected.
The feds concluded that the reports failed to incorporate 2024 near-miss data as well as make proper risk calculations for worker exposure to danger, and did not properly classify overall risk.
New York City’s transit system has been bogged down by a number of safety issues. James Keivom“Internal audits conducted by NYCT over the last year … reveal numerous and recurring violations of critical RWP safety rules,” Molinaro told NYCT president Demetrius Crichlow on Tuesday.
“These violations raise serious concerns that the procedures specifically designed to mitigate underlying safety risk are not being effectively implemented.”
Molinaro warned that NYCT will get one more chance to submit a proper report and that failure to do so would be viewed as a “pattern or practice of serious safety violations.”
“Failure … may lead FTA to take prompt enforcement actions,” he warned. “… including (1) directing NYCT to use Federal financial assistance to correct safety deficiencies; (2) withholding up to 25 percent of financial assistance … and (3) issuing restrictions or prohibitions as necessary and appropriate to address unsafe conditions.”






