Logo

UNITED NATIONS — Russia on Wednesday vetoed a U.N. Security Council resolution that would set up an international criminal court to prosecute those responsible for shooting down a Malaysia Airlines plane over Ukraine a year ago.

The foreign ministers of the Netherlands, Australia and Ukraine attended a meeting over the downing that killed all 298 people on board Flight MH17. The countries are among the five nations investigating the incident, along with Malaysia and Belgium.

Ukraine and the West suspect the plane, traveling from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur, was hit by a surface-to-air missile fired by Russian soldiers or Russia-backed separatist rebels on July 17, 2014. Russia denies that, and state media have alleged the plane was shot down by a Ukrainian missile or warplane.

“Russia has callously disregarded the public outcry in the grieving nations,” U.S. Ambassador Samantha Power said, adding that the United States was among the 18 countries that lost citizens in the disaster.

Foreign Minister Julie Bishop of Australia, which lost 39 citizens, said, “The veto only compounds the atrocity.” Three countries abstained from the vote: China, Angola and Venezuela, whose ambassador said victims’ suffering shouldn’t be used politically.

1 of 23
From left, Mo, Otis and Evie Norris, who died along with the grandfather Nick Morris.
From left, crash victims Mo, Otis and Evie Norris, who died along with grandfather Nick Morris
Nick Morris
Advertisement
Quinn Lucas Schansman
Quinn Lucas Schansman was the only American citizen on board. Facebook
World Health Organization (WHO) spokesperson Glenn Thomas.
World Health Organization (WHO) spokesperson Glenn Thomas.EPA
British victim John Alder
AP
Advertisement
An Indonesian passenger Hendry Se is seen at her graduation.
An Indonesian passenger Hendry Se is seen at her graduation. Getty Images
Dutchman Arthur Laumann holds a floral tribute and photograph of family friend Wayan Sujana of Bali.
Dutchman Arthur Laumann holds a floral tribute and photograph of family friend Wayan Sujana of Bali.Getty Images
Wayan Sujana
Wayan Sujana Getty Images
Advertisement
Melbourne couple Elaine Teoh and Emiel Mahler were traveling to a wedding in Malaysia.
Melbourne couple Elaine Teoh and Emiel Mahler were traveling to a wedding in Malaysia.
Elaine Teoh
Elaine Teoh
Ninik Yuriani of Indonesia.
Ninik Yuriani of IndonesiaGetty Images
Advertisement
The grieving sister of Ninik Yuriani.
The grieving sister of Ninik YurianiGetty Images
Widi Yuliono, a relative of John Paulisen holds up a photographs of Paulisen with Yuli Hastini, and children Arjuna Martin Paulisen, left, and Sri Paulisen.
A relative holds up a photograph of John Paulisen with Yuli Hastini and children Arjuna Martin Paulisen (left) and Sri Paulisen.EPA
A relative shows a photograph and John Paulisen and Yuli Hastini.
A relative shows a photograph of John Paulisen and Yuli Hastini. EPA
Advertisement
Crew member Shazana Salleh
Crew member Shazana Salleh
Crew member Azrina Yakob
Jennifer Van Der Leij
Jennifer Van Der Leij
Advertisement

Wednesday’s vote followed a last-minute effort to lobby Russian President Vladimir Putin, who has said setting up a tribunal would not make sense while the investigation continued.

The Dutch ambassador to the U.N., Karel van Oosterom, tweeted a statement saying Prime Minister Mark Rutte told Putin that “it was preferable to make a decision about the tribunal before the facts and charges have been established precisely in order to avoid politicizing the prosecution process.”

But the Kremlin quoted Putin as saying a tribunal would be “inexpedient” because Russia still has “a lot of questions” about the investigation to which it had little access.

Russia had offered its own draft that demanded justice for those responsible for the crash without calling for a tribunal. Russian Ambassador Vitaly Churkin told the council after the vote that such a tribunal risked not being impartial and being subject to media “propaganda,” and he called past tribunals for the Rwanda genocide and the violence in the former Yugoslavia “expensive.”

Ministers from the five investigating countries, along with allies in the 15-member council, later stressed that other legal options are available, but some acknowledged that a tribunal established by the council remains the best option. Some indicated they might pursue it again.

1 of 63
Flight MH17 disaster
The final picture of MH17 as it takes off from Amsterdam just hours before it was shot down over Ukraine.Getty Images
A firefighter works to put out a fire among the wreckage of Flight MH17
A firefighter works to put out a fire among the wreckage of Flight MH17Getty Images
Advertisement
Getty Images
Self-proclaimed Prime Minister of the pro-Russian separatist "Donetsk People's Republic" Alexander Borodai, center, stands as he arrives on the site of the crash .
Self-proclaimed Prime Minister of the pro-Russian separatist "Donetsk People's Republic" Alexander Borodai, center, stands as he arrives on the site of the crash .Getty Images
Reuters
Advertisement
A miner pulls out a piece of debris from a sunflower field.
A miner pulls out a piece of debris from a sunflower field. Getty Images
A group of miners rest after searching for debris and human remains in a sunflower field.
A group of miners rest after searching for debris and human remains in a sunflower field. Getty Images
Reuters
Advertisement
EPA
A member of the Ukrainian Emergency Ministry walks past a white flag marking the location of a body
A member of the Ukrainian Emergency Ministry walks past a white flag marking the location of a bodyReuters
A body is covered by a blanket.
A body is covered by a blanket. Getty Images
Advertisement
A journalist takes photographs at the crash site.
A journalist takes photographs at the crash site.Reuters
A Ukrainian police officer searches for human remains.
A Ukrainian police officer searches for human remains.Getty Images
People search for bodies.
People search for bodies.Getty Images
Advertisement
AP
Pieces of wreckage of the Malaysia Airlines flight MH17 are pictured on July 18, 2014 in Shaktarsk, the day after it crashed. Getty Images
Flight MH17 disaster
AP
Advertisement
Getty Images
Getty Images
Flight MH17 disaster
The crash site near the town of Shaktarsk, in rebel-held eastern UkraineGetty Images
Advertisement
Flight MH17 disaster
Getty Images
People stand on the wreckage of the downed airliner.
People stand on the wreckage of the downed airliner.
Flight MH17 disaster
Getty Images
Advertisement
Flight MH17 disaster
Getty Images
Flight MH17 disaster
Getty Images
Getty Images
Advertisement
Flight MH17 disaster
Getty Images
Flight MH17 disaster
Getty Images
Flight MH17 disaster
Getty Images
Advertisement
Flight MH17 disaster
Emergencies Ministry members work at the Malaysia Airlines crash site.Reuters
Advertisement
Flight MH17 disaster
A still-smoking part of the crash siteReuters
Flight MH17 disaster
Smoke rises at the crash site of Malaysia Airlines Flight MH17.AP
Advertisement
Flight MH17 disaster
Reuters
Flight MH17 disaster
Reuters
Advertisement
Flight MH17 disaster
Reuters
Flight MH17 disaster
An armed pro-Russian separatist stands at the crash site.Reuters
Flight MH17 disaster
Advertisement
Flight MH17 disaster
Reuters
Flight MH17 disaster
Reuters
Malaysia Airlines flight MH17's flight path.
Malaysia Airlines Flight MH17's flight pathFlightAware.com
Advertisement
People walk through what appears to be the airplane's interior.
People walk through what appears to be the airplane's interior.
People walk through what appears to be the airplane's interior.
Reuters
Russian 9K37 medium-range surface-to-air missilesGetty Images
Advertisement

“We will very quickly agree on the next step,” Dutch Foreign Minister Bert Koenders told reporters. “I assure you we haven’t lost time.”

The foreign ministers also met Wednesday morning with U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon, who called for justice and accountability.

A preliminary report released in the Netherlands last year said the plane had no technical problems in the seconds before it broke up in the sky after being struck by multiple objects — a conclusion that experts said likely pointed to a missile strike.

The investigation led by the Dutch Safety Board aims only to determine the crash cause, not to ascribe blame. The probe is being led by The Netherlands because 196 of the victims were Dutch.

A separate probe by the Dutch national prosecutor’s office aims to establishing who was responsible. This investigation includes authorities from Ukraine, Malaysia and other countries whose nationals were among the victims, but Russia is not a participant.

One possibility that wasn’t discussed Wednesday is the International Criminal Court, which takes on cases of war crimes, crimes against humanity or genocide in states that can’t or won’t take on the matter themselves.

1 of 22
Mourners gather in Kiev, Ukraine, last year to remember the 298 souls lost on MH17.EPA
A woman lights a candle near a placard reading "Stop Russian terrorism!"
A woman lights a candle in Kiev near a placard reading "Stop Russian terrorism!"Getty Images
Advertisement
Mourners in Kiev commemorate passengers of Malaysia Airlines Flight MH17.Getty Images
Getty Images
Reuters
Advertisement
Getty Images
Getty Images
Getty Images
Advertisement
Getty Images
A woman stands with sign reading 'Putin is a murderer.'
A woman stands in Kiev with sign reading "Putin is a murderer."EPA
EPA
Advertisement
A woman lies holding a sign that reads, "Putin is a murderer."
A woman lies with a sign that reads, "Putin is a murderer."Reuters
Getty Images
A woman holds a sign that reads, "Putin is a terrorist."
A woman in Kiev holds a sign that reads, "Putin is a terrorist."Reuters
Advertisement
Reuters
Reuters
Advertisement

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy