WhatsApp is claiming that a new lawsuit accusing it of failing to encrypt users’ communications is simply retaliation from an Israeli spyware company it has been battling for years.
The longstanding fight pits Mark Zuckerberg’s Meta Platforms-owned WhatsApp against the NSO Group, which is led by investors helmed by Hollywood powerhouse producer Robert Simonds — and whose infamous chief hacking tool is known as Pegasus.
In one of the latest legal rounds between them, a federal judge ordered NSO to pay Meta Platforms $4 million in punitive damages for targeting Meta users with its spyware.
WhatsApp is lashing out at an Israeli spyware firm it claims is behind a new lawsuit against it. NurPhoto via Getty ImagesThe law firm representing NSO in that case is allegedly now behind another lawsuit from plaintiffs who sued WhatsApp on Friday over privacy issues, leading Meta executives to cry foul.
“For a decade, WhatsApp has protected messages with end-to-end encryption so that no one else can read them,” said WhatsApp chief Will Cathcart in a statement to The Post on Monday.
“This lawsuit has no merit and is a distraction peddled by the same law firm defending NSO group from a court injunction barring their operations.
“We’re pushing back because it’s important everyone stands up against spyware that threatens people’s ability to communicate freely and securely.”
People familiar with both lawsuits offered conflicting opinions, with some viewing NSO’s complaint as part of a broader effort by it to go after WhatsApp and others saying the two cases had no bearing on each other.
Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg bought WhatsApp in 2014. AP
WhatsApp has stood firm against those opposed to its end-to-end messaging encryption. Sara Michilin – stock.adobe.comThe Biden administration had placed NSO on the Department of Commerce’s trade “blacklist” for “malicious cyber activities” in late 2021, imposing some licensing requirements on the firm.
NSO’s Pegasus system was most infamously alleged to have been used by the Saudi Arabian government to spy on Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi before his murder, as well as 189 other journalists.
David Friedman, President Trump’s US ambassador to Israel during his first term, was eventually made NSO’s executive chairman to burnish the spyware company’s reputation in the US, the Wall Street Journal reported last year.
This is a view of the Israeli cyber company NSO Group site in the Arava Desert in 2021 in Sapir, Israel. Getty Images
Zuckerberg cozied up to the Trump administration during its latest transition to the White House. APIn the suit filed last week against Meta, plaintiffs from Brazil, South Africa, India and Australia allege that their WhatsApp messages are not private as promised.
They claimed that whistleblowers, who were not immediately identified, have found billions more users with their encrypted communications accessible.
David Friedman, Trump’s US ambassador to Israel during his first term, was made NSO’s executive chairman to burnish the spyware company’s reputation in the US, the Wall Street Journal reported. NurPhoto via Getty ImagesAdam Wolfson, a partner with plaintiff law firm Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, alleges in the suit that Meta employees only need to ask an engineer for access, which is then granted “often without any scrutiny at all.”
“WhatsApp’s denials have all been carefully worded in a way that stops short of denying the central allegation in the complaint — that Meta has the ability to read WhatsApp messages, regardless of its claims about end-to-end encryption,” he told The Post.
A Meta rep called the suit “frivolous” and vowed that the company would “pursue sanctions against plaintiff’s counsel.”
A third suit was also filed in an Israeli court against WhatsApp on Monday.
Meta CEO Muck Zuckerberg had cozied up to the Trump administration during its latest White House transition, but the newer suit has already gained the attention of some of the president’s allies such as tech mogul Elon Musk, who urged his platform’s users to take up X Chat instead of WhatsApp.
“WhatsApp is not secure,” Musk said.
Previously under the Biden administration, the Commerce Department’s Bureau of Industry and Security placed NSO on its entity list “for engaging in activities that are contrary to the national security or foreign policy interests of the United States.”
One source familiar with that move described it as “entirely political” and without “the interests of American law enforcement and intelligence at heart.
“The reason NSO went on this list is simply because this is an effective tool by the Israeli government to stop Palestinian terrorism,” the source said, noting that Biden admin officials never explained why when a final rule blacklisting the spyware firm was published in the Federal Register in November 2021.
But critics familiar with NSO’s legal proceedings have claimed the firm’s products are “rife for abuse” by malign actors.
Proponents of the spyware tools have emphasized that the Israeli government maintains veto authority over any improper use of the technology and that NSO monitors those using it for compliance.
Reps for the Commerce Department and NSO did not respond to Post requests for comment.






